User
Write something
PERFUMER'S EDITION: FAVORITE FRAGRANCE REVIEW #2
XERJOFF XJ 1861 NAXOS Going Beyond the Notes: Understanding the Materials Behind the Fragrance Today, we're taking a closer look at one of the most recognizable fragrances in the niche perfume world: Xerjoff Naxos. Naxos is part of Xerjoff's XJ 1861 collection, inspired by Italy and its rich cultural heritage. It brings together aromatic freshness, honeyed sweetness, warm spices, and tobacco. But for this Perfumer's Edition, we're going beyond how the fragrance smells and exploring the raw materials Xerjoff discloses, their odor profiles, their functions in perfumery, and how the remaining accords might be constructed. THE OFFICIAL NOTE BREAKDOWN Top: Lemon, Bergamot, Lavender, Incense from Oman Heart: Jasmine Sambac, Honey, Cinnamon, Cashmere Base: Vanilla, Tobacco Leaf, Tonka Bean Now, let's get into the chemistry behind the fragrance. THE KNOWN RAW MATERIALS Unlike simply reading the note pyramid, we can examine Xerjoff's published ingredient declaration, which identifies a number of actual botanical materials and aromatic compounds. 1. Linalool: Smell: Fresh, floral, lavender-like, slightly citrusy and woody. Purpose: Frequently used to build lavender and aromatic floral accords. It creates freshness, contributes floral lift, and helps connect citrus notes with the floral heart. 2. Linalyl Acetate Smell: Sweet, clean, lavender-like, slightly bergamot-like, and fruity. Purpose: One of the characteristic odor compounds associated with lavender. It softens herbal sharpness and contributes a smooth, fresh aromatic quality. 3. Coumarin Smell: Sweet freshly cut hay, tonka bean, almond-like warmth, and subtle vanilla. Purpose: A foundational material in many fougère fragrances. It adds sweetness, warmth, and a distinctive hay-like character. It can help bridge lavender, tobacco, and gourmand accords. 4. Vanillin Smell: Sweet, creamy, familiar vanilla with warm balsamic nuances. Purpose: Adds recognizable vanilla sweetness, warmth, and body. It can soften harsher woody or tobacco-like effects and enrich gourmand compositions.
PERFUMER'S EDITION: FAVORITE FRAGRANCE REVIEW #2
Reaching bottom of the sample
So I've been searching for a professional office daily driver and I found myself glued to Creed's Original Vetiver. For my taste, I dont need a lot of sprays and I can live with 6 hours of longevity. What I crave is the scent itself and the mood it puts me end. And OV was really scratching that itch for me, so when the sample I have of it ran out today, I had my first "empty bottle" experience. I've been at this hobby now for about a year and it's time to buy the full bottle.
Match #77
Match #77—the penultimate matchup. After more than two months of daily head-to-head testing, we're down to three fragrances. Today's match determines which one earns the right to face Terre d'Hermès Eau Givrée in tomorrow's championship final. And it's another painful one: Bleu de Chanel EDP versus Tom Ford Ombré Leather. Bleu de Chanel has proven itself over and over throughout this tournament. I've called it the gold standard for blue fragrances, and I stand by that. Citrus, ginger, and incense over amber, cedar, and sandalwood create something extraordinarily versatile, mature, and sophisticated. It never needs to shout. It just smells classy. Ombré Leather couldn't be more different. It's darker, richer, and far more assertive. But what keeps drawing me back is how beautifully smooth it is. That gorgeous leather note blends with cardamom, jasmine, amber, patchouli, and moss to create something powerful without ever becoming rough or overwhelming. I love both of these fragrances. I'm keeping both of these fragrances. And on a different day, for a different occasion, I could easily prefer the Chanel. But today I'm choosing the Tom Ford. There's something about that combination of darkness and smoothness—and that magnificent leather accord—that makes Ombré Leather one of the most compelling fragrances in my collection. Tom Ford Ombré Leather survives. Bleu de Chanel EDP is eliminated from the tournament. And with that, the last Chanel finally falls. After 77 matchups, we're down to two: Terre d'Hermès Eau Givrée vs. Tom Ford Ombré Leather. My favorite spring/summer fragrance against my favorite autumn/winter fragrance. Tomorrow, somehow, I'm supposed to choose just one.
Match #77
Match #78 – The Final Match
Match #78. The final. Terre d'Hermès Eau Givrée vs. Tom Ford Ombré Leather. Admittedly, this is a bit of an anti-climax. We just had this exact matchup on Day 75, and I'm not going to manufacture suspense where there isn't any. I chose Eau Givrée then, and I'm choosing it again today. These have emerged as my two favorite seasonal fragrances in the collection. Ombré Leather is my autumn/winter choice: dark, smooth, luxurious leather blended beautifully with cardamom, amber, patchouli, jasmine, and moss. Eau Givrée is my spring/summer favorite: that spectacular blast of bright citrus followed by juniper, pepper, mineral notes, and woods. Both are wonderful. Both will get plenty of wear. But Terre d'Hermès Eau Givrée wins the tournament. So after 78 days, have I definitively identified the best fragrance I own? Well...not exactly. That's because I committed to the original 40-fragrance field more than two months ago, and apparently I have a fragrance-buying problem. Since then, I've added several bottles that could have made a serious run in this tournament: YSL Tuxedo, Guerlain L'Homme Idéal Cologne Forte, Dior Homme Intense, Armani I Will, and Armani Code Parfum. Given what I've learned about my tastes during this experiment, I suspect a few of those would have gone very deep. But that was partly the point of this whole ridiculous exercise. Reading reviews and looking at ratings can tell me what other people think. Wearing two fragrances side by side, day after day, forced me to decide what I actually prefer. And after 78 days of admittedly obsessive fragrance nerdiness, I have a much clearer understanding of what I enjoy: smoothness, sophistication, fragrances that develop beautifully through the drydown, and enough character to remain interesting without simply shouting for attention. And apparently I really, really like Terre d'Hermès Eau Givrée. So congratulations to the champion. 🏆 And thanks to everyone who followed along, commented, disagreed with my decisions, or simply tolerated this marathon for the past two-plus months.
Match #78 – The Final Match
Match #75
Match #75 decides the champion of the main bracket—and I'm still not entirely sure I've made the right decision. It's my favorite spring/summer fragrance, Terre d'Hermès Eau Givrée, against my favorite autumn/winter fragrance, Tom Ford Ombré Leather. I've leaned both ways over the past several hours. Even as I'm writing this, I'm wavering. This is where I really wish I had Michelle here to break the tie. Eau Givrée is already thoroughly Michelle-approved. In fact, she chose it for me so often during my last trip to Hong Kong that I completely emptied my travel atomizer. Ombré Leather hasn't had the Michelle test yet because I don't have a travel spray for it. That's something I'll need to correct. Eau Givrée has been the revelation of this tournament for me. That brilliant citron, juniper, and Timut pepper opening is wonderfully refreshing, but it's the way the mineral and woody elements emerge underneath that has made me love it. It's bright without being simplistic and sophisticated without losing that sparkling freshness. Ombré Leather is nearly its mirror image: dark, rich, smooth leather surrounded by cardamom, amber, patchouli, jasmine, and moss. It's luxurious, powerful, and beautifully blended. In cooler weather or for a date night, I'm not sure I own anything I'd rather wear. So how do I separate two fragrances that are almost perfect for completely different purposes? Barely. Other than the considerable difference in price, the one distinction I can find is versatility. Eau Givrée simply gives me more opportunities to wear it during the year. And apparently that's enough. Terre d'Hermès Eau Givrée wins Match #75 and becomes champion of the main bracket. Tom Ford Ombré Leather drops into the second-chance bracket, where it awaits the winner of tomorrow's matchup. Three challengers remain, but Eau Givrée now sits alone at the top. And if you're a betting man, I wouldn't put much money on any of them knocking it off. But considering how much I've changed my mind during this tournament, I probably shouldn't be trusted with betting advice.
Match #75
1-30 of 638
Brotherhood Of Scent
#1 Fragrance Community 🏆
Our mission is to help YOU leverage the power of scent to become the man you know yourself to be.
Leaderboard (30-day)
Powered by