Activity
Mon
Wed
Fri
Sun
Dec
Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
What is this?
Less
More
629 contributions to Brotherhood Of Scent
A Brief Farewell and a SOTD – PDM Carlisle
Brothers, today's SOTD will be my last review until sometime in mid-November. Yes, I'm bringing my recent hot streak of daily fragrance reviews to an end, but I think I have a pretty good excuse. I'll be traveling 12 time zones away to spend some much-anticipated time with Michelle, including celebrating her birthday together. And frankly, that's a trade I'm more than happy to make! But before I disappear for a few weeks, there's one more fragrance to explore. Today's SOTD is Parfums de Marly Carlisle, another sample from a house that has been making a very favorable impression on me lately. And Carlisle is quite a way to finish this run. This is a rich, dark, substantial fragrance that seems tailor-made for cold weather. The dominant notes, at least to my nose, are patchouli and vanilla, and they make a terrific combination. The patchouli brings an earthy, slightly mysterious depth, while the vanilla provides a smooth sweetness that softens the darker elements. But there's more going on beneath the surface. Tonka bean, nutmeg, apple, and rose all contribute to the composition, adding warmth, spice, and subtle fruity and floral accents. They're not necessarily competing for attention, though. The patchouli and vanilla are unquestionably the stars of this particular show. The result is a bold, sophisticated fragrance with plenty of personality. It's not something I'd reach for on a hot summer afternoon, but on a crisp autumn evening or a genuinely cold winter day? Absolutely. I've been impressed by how many different approaches Parfums de Marly takes to its fragrances. Layton, Herod, Althaïr, Percival, and now Carlisle have all given me something to appreciate, even though they're very different experiences. And then for summer fresh fragrances, we have Sedley and Greenley. Of course, the challenge is deciding which ones deserve a place in an already growing collection, especially at PDM prices. Carlisle has certainly earned further consideration, but I'll want to spend more time with the sample before making any decisions.
A Brief Farewell and a SOTD – PDM Carlisle
4 likes • 17d
@Jeff Beason Thank you, sir!
Noel got his account banned by big fragrance
https://www.tiktok.com/t/ZPLAQfFQk/ Not sure if anyone follows Noel, but his account was banned for comparing Amouage and Creed to more affordable dupes he was recommending for people on a budget. Sounds like it is happening to more and more fragrance creators.
1 like • 17d
@Mark DiCiero Yes, this surprised me too. You can't copyright or patent a fragrance, although the marketing materials are protected and clone house get in trouble for copycat bottles and names at times. But the scent is apparently fair game, which doesn't make sense to me. I have no idea why this distributor is going after reviewers, though. They have every right to publish their opinions in videos.
Nobilis Group Boycott
The fragrance world is in a massive uproar as luxury distributor Nobilis Group faces a fierce boycott from the online community. The controversy erupted after the corporate entity launched an aggressive legal and digital crackdown against budget-friendly perfume "dupe" brands. To protect its high-end brand equity, Nobilis successfully sued clone giant ÉCLAT, legally banning them from using "smells like" comparisons or utilizing consumer reviews to market affordable alternatives to luxury fragrances. However, the corporate victory quickly triggered a massive backlash when Nobilis began issuing intellectual property strikes against social media influencers. The outrage peaked when popular creator Noel Deyzel's secondary account, "Noel Smells," which had 1.8 million followers, was permanently banned from TikTok for reviewing affordable clones. Other fragrance reviewers have reported content strikes and video deletions, causing a wave of censorship fear that has forced creators to actively scrub the word "dupe" from their channels. In retaliation, the online community has mobilized a widespread boycott targeting the prestigious luxury and niche brands distributed by Nobilis, including powerhouse names like Creed, Xerjoff, and Amouage. Enthusiasts and creators are rallying fans to stop purchasing these high-end scents in hopes that the luxury perfume houses will pull their distribution contracts from Nobilis over the unfolding public relations disaster. Meanwhile, support is surging for budget alternative houses like ÉCLAT, Bujairami, and Vantage. What started as a corporate legal battle over marketing definitions has officially transformed into a digital class war, pitting everyday consumers and independent creators fighting for affordable scent alternatives against corporate entities accused of greed and censorship. Share your thoughts on this and tell me if does it color your future purchases?
10 likes • 17d
It seems to me going after reviewers online is a foolish approach. If they have legitimate complaints with a dupe house for violating marketing brands, etc., they should address them with the manufacturers rather than reviewers. You can't patent a scent, I believe, but some dupe houses clearly cut close to the bone with their copycat bottles and marketing. But I admit I come to this debate from the book world and as a writer, I'm very protective of my copyright property. Emotionally, I think the perfumers who create a scent should be the ones benefitting from it. But realistically, I know clone houses are allowed to reverse engineer the scent. It's murky to me. So my position on top of the fence isn't very stable.
Fragrance Math makes total sense lol
https://www.instagram.com/reel/Dexk_BLB7RT/?rpxt=MTlxb2FuNGt3Y2xyaQ==
7 likes • 17d
I just sent this to my fiancée, who is also into fragrances, and PDM Delina is her favorite. I have a feeling we'll be saving a fortune next year buying PDM bottles.
SOTD – Tom Ford Oud Wood
Today's SOTD is Tom Ford Oud Wood, a fragrance I've had in my sample collection for quite some time but haven't worn in about a year. And there's a reason for that. The last time I wore Oud Wood, I was visiting Michelle in Hong Kong. Unfortunately, neither of us particularly enjoyed it. But in retrospect, I'm wondering whether the fragrance itself was the problem—or whether wearing a rich, woody fragrance in Hong Kong's heat and humidity was simply a terrible idea. Today, with temperatures finally beginning to feel something like autumn, I decided to give it another chance. And what a difference! This is a beautifully composed fragrance, with that smooth, sophisticated blending I've come to expect from Tom Ford. The oud, Brazilian rosewood, and sandalwood create a distinctive woody foundation, while a gentle vanilla creaminess softens the composition and gives it a wonderfully luxurious character. There's something striking about the combination. It's rich and distinctive without feeling harsh, and I'm appreciating nuances today that I certainly didn't notice during that unfortunate Hong Kong experiment. Which brings me to an interesting dilemma. Did Michelle dislike Oud Wood, or did she simply dislike Oud Wood in tropical weather? Because those are two very different things. I've learned that the circumstances in which we wear a fragrance can have an enormous influence on how we experience it. Temperature, humidity, occasion, and even our mood can change our impressions considerably. And given how much I enjoy Tom Ford's approach to leather and woody fragrances, I'm reluctant to dismiss Oud Wood based on one disappointing experience under less-than-ideal conditions. Fortunately, I still have a little left in the sample. So I'm going to save it for an opportunity to wear it around Michelle in genuinely cool weather. That should help settle the question once and for all. After all, I already know that I like it considerably more today than I did a year ago. Now I need to find out whether she feels the same way.
SOTD – Tom Ford Oud Wood
1 like • 17d
@Raymond Reeves Haha, the problem is it never gets cold where she is, so I'm going to have to save it until she gets to the US (early 2027, we hope).
3 likes • 17d
@Jon Jacobs A man of excellent taste! I need to do that survey.
1-10 of 629
Robert Sheard
8
24,415 points to level up
@robert-sheard-5918
I'm a semi-retired writer, teacher, speech and debate coach. I am currently the Director of the BookTube Prize and hope to write more books.

Active 10d ago
Joined Dec 11, 2025
INTJ
Durham, North Carolina, USA
Powered by