This might be one of my biggest marketing mistakes yet, and I want to share it because there’s an important lesson in it. For a long time, most of our traffic came inbound through SEO. We were getting 10's of thousands of organic clicks, and I also had an understanding of exactly which pages were driving qualified leads and which were simply generating traffic. Then, a little over a year ago, I noticed a major shift in the search results. AI Overviews were taking traffic away from top-of-funnel content, and within a few months, our organic traffic dropped by roughly 30%. I didn’t pay much attention to it. I told myself that a lot of our content wasn’t very good anyway. Some of it attracted the wrong audience, and SEO was changing, so I needed to focus on other acquisition channels. There was some truth to that story. But because part of it was true, I stopped questioning the rest of it. Fast-forward a year, and our organic traffic had fallen by around 70%. I was busy, so I still didn’t take the time to properly investigate it. I continued believing the same story: AI was taking the traffic. The content wasn’t great. SEO was becoming less valuable. It was time to move on. I finally decided to dig into the data because, despite the decline, we were starting to gain more visibility inside LLMs, and traditional search was still capable of creating value. What I found was difficult to admit. Yes, AI changed the search landscape. But I had also made some major technical SEO mistakes over the past year, particularly during our website migration away from WordPress. Had I caught and corrected those mistakes earlier, our organic traffic probably wouldn’t have taken nearly as large of a hit. The good news is that I’ve identified the problems and started working through plan to fix them. But the honest truth is that I screwed up. I created a story in my head, found enough evidence to support it, and then kept believing it... even while the data was trying to tell me something different.