Exactly one year ago, I bought a 5 ml sample of Creed Royal Oud, based on an influencer's recommendation (Sebastian Jara). When I first tried it, I found it to be very "meh", and rated it only a '3' on my 1-5 scale. In other words, okay, but not worth buying again. Today I decided to give it a Second Chance. As soon as I applied the first spray, I was amazed at how much this frag had "changed". This was a real paradigm shift!
What I formerly described as "Pleasant, but not lasting" had now morphed into an amazing scent. It received a highly updated descriptor in my tracking sheet: "Heavenly opening with citrus & cedar. I soon sense more underlying wood, not sure if it's oud. Heart is softly aromatic, powdery, with more musky woods coming forward." Royal Oud has been upgraded from '3' to '5' for me, and I'm now thinking of acquiring a full bottle, tester, or a Rescented orphan.
Why and how does it happen that our perception of a fragrance can change so dramatically over time? I think a strong argument can be made that our olfactory organ has much to learn over time, if we will only teach it. Like many who are new to this hobby, it was easy for me, a year ago, to believe that because my nose had served me well all my life, I was right to trust it's judgement as I began my foray into this hobby ( which I recently heard described as "Fragrance Wardrobing" ). But as I tried new scents over many months, seeking to discover what I like, or don't like, a funny thing happened: My nose became more perceptive, just as my scent preferences matured. The end result is that some things can smell just a bit different now than they did before - and this is a result I was not expecting!
So don't be afraid to try new fragrances ... but also don't forget to give your dismissed scents a Second Chance too!