Fresh Start October Day 6 Educational (Do Clones and Designers Maintain Value?

🔥

The resale value of fragrances varies significantly depending on whether the item is a designer or clone fragrance. Clones have very low resale value, while designer perfumes can hold or increase in value under specific conditions, particularly if they are discontinued.

Resale value of designer fragrances

The resale value of designer fragrances is highly inconsistent and depends on several key factors. Most mainstream fragrances, once opened or even just purchased from a discounter, lose value immediately, similar to buying a new car. However, some designer and niche perfumes can become collector's items.

Key factors that influence designer perfume resale value:

Discontinuation: The most significant factor driving value appreciation is a fragrance being discontinued. When a beloved scent is taken off the market, the remaining bottles become sought-after commodities for collectors and fans who want to stock up. (Think ADG Profumo or Dior Home Parfum the older batches or original the ones that the vast majority of people consider materpieces)
Rarity and demand: The price of a discontinued fragrance is driven by the number of remaining bottles and the level of public demand. Scents with a dedicated following can command very high prices on resale markets like eBay or Facebook.
Condition and completeness: A bottle that is full or nearly full, in excellent condition, and still has its original box will be worth significantly more than a used bottle with missing packaging.
Original formulation: Older, "vintage" formulations are often preferred by collectors over newer reformulations, as ingredients and formulas can change over time. This makes vintage bottles more desirable and valuable.
The fragrance house: Certain brands like Guerlain, Chanel, and Christian Dior have a long history of creating highly desirable scents. Their discontinued and vintage offerings often perform well on the collector's market.

Resale value of clone fragrances

Clone fragrances, which are less expensive scents designed to smell like popular designer and niche perfumes, have little to no resale value.

Key factors for the low resale value of clone fragrances:

Low retail price: Since clones are already sold at a fraction of the cost of the original designer perfume, the margin for reselling them for a profit is practically nonexistent.
Buyer risk: The resale market is built on trust, and a buyer is taking on the risk of receiving a counterfeit or a tampered-with bottle. For a low-priced clone, the risk and hassle of reselling are not worth it for most buyers.
Uncertain quality: Many clone fragrances are created with plain packaging and low-cost ingredients to keep costs down. This means that a used bottle of a clone has less perceived value than a used bottle from a reputable house.
Abundant supply: Clones are readily available at retail and from online discounters. There is no scarcity to drive up prices on the secondary market, unlike with a rare or discontinued designer fragrance.

Resale market summary:

Feature Designer FragrancesClone FragrancesTypical ValueSignificant loss of value after initial purchase, unless specific conditions are met.Very low or no resale value, rarely worth the hassle.Value DriversDiscontinuation, vintage formulations, rarity, brand reputation, and excellent condition.Not applicable. Buyers have no incentive to pay for a used, low-cost product.Collector AppealHigh, especially for discontinued or limited-edition items.Low to none. The market is not driven by collectors, but by cost-conscious conumers best Strategy. For average scents, sell soon to recover some cost. For potentially rare bottles, save them in optimal conditions for long-term appreciation.Sell only for a nominal price or give them away. They are not investments.

15 comments