Activity
Mon
Wed
Fri
Sun
Nov
Dec
Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
What is this?
Less
More
24 contributions to Brotherhood Of Scent
SOTD: Terre d’Hermès edt by Hermès 24/08/2026
Released in 2006, this landmark creation was the work of legendary perfumer Jean-Claude Ellena, and I think it’s fair to say it redefined what a mainstream men’s fragrance could be at the time. The concept was simple to capture the essence of the earth itself, minerals, soil, sunlight, and stone. Rather than leaning into the usual citrus, aquatic, or heavy spice trends of the time. It was originally launched as a unisex offering, but its quiet gravitation and understated power made it an instant staple among men, and it’s remained one of the most respected and recognizable fragrances in the game for nearly two decades. There’s a reason you’ll find it on shelves in almost every country on the planet. Opening up, you get a sharp, zesty hit of grapefruit and orange that’s bright and crisp, but it doesn’t hang around long. Within minutes that citrus fades back and the real heart of the fragrance starts to show. Earthy, mineral-rich vetiver mixes with peppery notes and a distinct flinty, stone-like quality that feels like standing on a sun-warmed rock face. It’s not loud or flashy; it’s grounded and contemplative. This is where Ellena’s genius really shows, he stripped everything right back, removed all the unnecessary noise, and let the natural character of the materials speak for themselves. There’s no sweetness here, no artificial vanilla, no heavy synthetics just pure, honest earth and spice that evolves slowly over hours without ever feeling heavy or cloying. As it dries down, Terre settles into a smooth, woody base of cedar and vetiver, with that same mineral flint running all the way through it. Performance is solid you’ll get 5-6 hours on skin with decent projection early on, before it settles into a soft, respectable skin scent that people will notice but won’t overpower a room. What makes it genuinely interesting is how it manages to feel both classic and modern at the same time; it one of those scents that doesn't age. It’s the kind of fragrance that works everywhere office, gym, dinner, weddings and it always looks and smells expensive. If you’re after something that commands respect without shouting, this is one of the safest and smartest picks you can make.
SOTD: Terre d’Hermès edt by Hermès 24/08/2026
11 likes • Aug 24
I don't get "earth" at all so much as I get . . . orange. Not complaining by any means, just saying.
Ideal sample size?
Over the past couple of months, I've been actively taking some advice of several brothers, and taking some time to enjoy the modest collection (12 bottles) I own, and really utilise them. It's been a very useful exercise, and has really helped to clarify my thinking in terms of which of the full bottles I own - I really, truly enjoy, which ones I quite like, but probably would look to move on from - and highlighted certain styles of fragrance I'd really like to explore in more depth - so first of all - thank you for the suggestions and guidance. My follow-up though was to ask you - what is your opinion on an 'ideal' sample size when you look to sample a scent you've never tried, but are intrigued by? Typically, when testing a new scent, I've opted for the 2ml version, (partly taking account of the pricing min/max analysis), however, I am now pondering whether 2ml is really sufficient, as it only affords one to two wears max. Am now thinking that ideally I need more wears to really get under the skin of a scent and fully understand if its worth pulling the trigger? What do you guys think?
5 likes • Aug 24
3-5ml. I used to think 2ml was enough too, but lately I've been having leaking issues when ordering from Scent Split. It's so little to work with in the first place, I can't have it be leaking on top of that!
Creed Iris Debonaire - First Sniff
Found myself with a very rare hour of down time this afternoon, and just happened to be close to Nordstrom's. I figured I'd stop in and see if I could get my hands on a sample of the Armani I Will fragrance that everyone is so excited about. I'll talk about that separately, but TLDR I think it's boring. After talking with the sales clerk a bit, I mentioned that i was a fan of Iris notes, and that I was hoping to get a sample of Gypsy Water Absolu. Unfortunately, they were out, but then she told me they had a tester of the new Creed Iris Debonaire that is set to release on September 8th. She was kind enough to give me a little decant, and I've been wearing it all afternoon. I have talked in the past about my dislike of Creed. I get the appeal, but I'm just not a fan. I really hate their pricing structure, and in the past, I've resolved not to buy their stuff. All of that to say, that Iris Debonaire may be my new favorite perfume. It's up their with Black Orchid, Gypsy Water, and Iris Obsidian. I can't stop sniffing my arm. It's an absolutely lovely fougere with a really sophisticated French Lavender note in the drydown. According to the marketing, the Iris used is specially made specifically for this fragrance. Whether that's bullshit or not, I don't know, but it works. This stuff is incredible. We'll see how it works performance wise. I want to wear it tomorrow, but it's going to be 110, and I don't think powdery iris works very well in that kind of heat, so I'll have to wait a bit until I have an office day or day at home when i don't have to go outside much. But wow. This might end up being an actual bottle purchase if I can save up and get a good discount.
Creed Iris Debonaire - First Sniff
0 likes • Aug 24
@Stephen DeMent Different strokes. I don't like iris at all and wish the glaze for DH Intense would just die already, haha. That being said, this new Creed doesn't smell very "powdery" to me. Doesn't mean I'm head over heels for it, but it's definitely treated differently than your typical "iris"-forward scent.
What's the Ideal Collection Size (For You)?
There have several interesting threads recently about collecting fragrances and philosophies behind collections. I'm only about two years into my own journey and have been buying new bottles regularly. (I think I have 42 or 43 bottles now.) And I've been thinking about trying to design an ideal (for me) fragrance wardrobe of 28 bottles: seven for each season. So just a quick poll: what's the ideal collection size for you? And if you'd like to explain in the comments, even better. Thanks, gentlemen.
Poll
34 members have voted
6 likes • Aug 17
I don't know if anyone else has done this, but lately I've been having a lengthy discussion over multiple threads with Chat GPT about "what I like" in fragrances. Or rather, to tell me what is the pattern in a long list of 42 "potential" fragrances that I happen to like (I don't own all of them whatsoever). With a lot of further clarifying questions, I've learned a lot about not just what I like, but why I like the things that I do. My philosophy basically boils down to the following: 1) It's gotta smell good (to me AS WELL AS to others) 2) It's gotta be of high-grade quality 3) It's gotta be a little unique; not full-blown ridiculous, but not super "common" either 4) It's gotta have at least decent longevity and/or projection for what it is 5) I don't like fragrances whose scent profiles "dictate" their utility. I like more versatility than that Then there's the flow of most common accords, notes, styles, fragrances families etc., that I like, with "accented" notes that are typical of my style. I'm a musician, and so Chat has been using that as analogous language to explain to me why certain fragrance patterns seem to keep recurring throughout my otherwise disparate-looking tastes. Out of those 42 "hypotheticals", I now have about a core 6-10 that I'd be very happy working through if that were all I had. It's about 40/60 designer/niche (MAYBE one clone), and that's it. I have about a dozen bottles or so and a smattering of samples and travel sticks, but I'd reconfigure my entire collection if I had the cash to splash. I'm doing it one bottle at a time though, now that I understand what I'm after. (If anyone's curious what that core 6-10 are for me, I'm happy to divulge further and explain why those in particular.) Anyway, I highly recommend using some sort of AI to help whittle down collections, if that's your thing. Or to figure out what you like so you don't overspend or blind buy till your broke. Luckily for me, I've managed to avoid all that because I'm poor to start. Have fun, gents! ✌️
4 likes • Aug 18
@Robert Sheard For sure! It was for me too 2 years ago when I first started. What I'd done over the years was input into a word document the names of various fragrances (which I constantly updated over that period of time), along with their accords, and note pyramid. I only did the Chat GPT thing in the past few weeks, but it's still been very informative and eye-opening.
What do you brothers think?
I’ve really been leaning into the clean boy, Mediterranean, linen oceanic look. I got pacific chill a while back and adore it, but I’m looking for a new summer freshie. So far I’m stuck between French Riviera by Mancera or Torino 21 by Xerjoff. I’d love to finally own a Xerjoff, and really enjoy the dna of this one, but it might be redundant as I already have a fragrance occupying the minty herbal fruity slot (pacific chill), so I’m leaning French Riviera now. I need more high quality marine fragrances as well. What do you brothers think?
Poll
32 members have voted
8 likes • Aug 8
Xerjoff Renaissance, or Roja Burlington 1819.
3 likes • Aug 10
@The Rain Society All good bro. Just wondered if you'd tried those yet. Keep grinding!
1-10 of 24
Kevin Garnica
5
351 points to level up
@kevin-garnica-5818
New to the hobby, began early 2024, but am a fast learner. I enjoy the non-tangible aspects of fragrances; the feelings, psychology, imagination, etc.

Active 12d ago
Joined Jun 25, 2024
ENTP
SoCal
Powered by