The Bolsheviks seized the Winter Palace in October 1917 and murdered the possibility of the most consequential free market experiment in human history before it ever began. Russia in 1917 was a vast, agrarian, partially industrializing empire with functioning private property in many sectors, a growing merchant class, active commodity markets in St. Petersburg, and a peasantry that had, since the Stolypin reforms of 1906, begun accumulating private land titles. The country was poor, yes. But poverty is not a fixed condition. It is a starting point. And Russia had every raw ingredient for the kind of capital accumulation that pulled Germany and Japan from ruin to prosperity within two generations. What Lenin's faction did instead is a tragedy. They abolished private land ownership; they nationalized the banks, and they collectivized grain production, which meant soldiers with rifles went to villages and seized food. The result was famine in 1921 and 1922, which killed five to ten million people. Lenin then partially reversed course with the New Economic Policy, essentially admitting the price system worked and central confiscation did not. Stalin then reversed the reversal, collectivized agriculture completely, and produced the Holodomor of 1932 to 1933, which killed another estimated five to seven million in Ukraine alone. Without private ownership of capital goods, there are no genuine market prices for those goods. Without prices, planners allocate resources by guesswork and politics. Factories produced what bureaucrats demanded, not what consumers valued. The Soviet Union built steel mills before roads, produced tractors without spare parts, and exported grain while peasants starved. The counterfactual is not utopian fantasy. Look at Finland, which broke from the Russian Empire in December 1917, secured property rights, maintained rule of law, and by 1980 had a per capita income twenty times higher than the Soviet Union at its peak. Geographic and cultural proximity makes this comparison clean.