Gucci Guilty Elixir (1/3) · Brotherhood Of Scent

Gucci Guilty Elixir (1/3)

After hearing a lot about it and seeing the hype around Quentin Bisch’s work, I finally got to try Gucci Guilty Elixir and was curious to see how it compares to Guilty Absolu de Parfum and the Love Edition, which I had tried previously.

The opening is super familiar, but done differently. That classic orange blossom is right there, but it’s deeper, with nutmeg and pimento adding depth and spice. Just when you think the orange blossom party is over, it comes back again, this time as an orange blossom absolute, paired with osmanthus and orris butter. Brilliant stuff. By this stage, the spices have settled down and it turns juicy, floral, sweet and smooth. Orange blossom holds the spotlight until you suddenly pick up vanilla and I genuinely thought, where did you come from? It’s a powdery style of vanilla, and alongside it you get ambrofix, patchouli and benzoin, which pull everything together and give the scent a refined, resinous feel.

The Gucci Guilty line has not disappointed me once. All the flankers I’ve tried so far have been excellent, and this is easily the most wearable while still smelling niche.

Performance is beastly. After 24 hours it’s still a skin scent on me, and on clothes it just keeps going. This is easily the longest-lasting fragrance I’ve tested. Projection was strong for the first 2 hrs, then moderate for another 4, before becoming more intimate around the 8-hr mark.

Compared to the other flankers, this one is probably the best across the board. As of now, my Gucci Guilty ranking is:

Elixir & Absolu de Parfum
Love Edition

All of them are good, but they give off very different vibes. Sun tan lotion for cooler days? Love Edition. Angels’ Share vibes? Absolu. Amouage Reflection Man vibes? Elixir. One of my housemate’s friends, who’s also into fragrances, said she liked the one was wearing.

Overall, I’m giving this a solid 9.5/10. Price is the reason im knocking some points off. I’m still slightly unsure which flanker I like more. Absolu has weaker performance on my skin, but that could’ve just been an off day. Elixir and Absolu are going head to head for me, both sitting at a 9.5. Owning both might be redundant, but if I can’t decide, I honestly wouldn’t mind having both.

What do you think of this fragrance? Is it your favourite from the Guilty line?

13 comments