I give grateful thanks to @Jon Underwood for a Skool conversation that triggered this train of thought. See - https://www.skool.com/stevekeen-free/garbage-from-the-uk-house-of-commons-library?p=f7f23363 Thinking about World X (X for exogenous money), when money was gold, has been useful because it exposed what happened in those bygone days, at the ‘moment of birth’ of old-fashioned commodity money. I hadn't realised that a declaration by the State must be made to create any kind of State money. In my example in the conversation, State-owned gold entered the Treasury as a physical asset. Now I can add a description of commodity money coming into existence by formal declaration - “Hear ye, hear ye. This physical asset is hereby transformed into a monetary asset. There has been a loss of physical assets, reducing the physical equity of the State. There has been a gain in monetary assets, increasing the monetary equity of the State. Let the State’s Accounts show that Transformation. Increase the Asset and Equity entries in those Accounts accordingly. Long live the State”. Two accounting entries were made when commodity money was born. Neither of them was a liability. Of course, that’s an unusual situation in the normal run of accounting when assets and liabilities occur in matched pairs. Something unusual did happen - commodity money was declared into being through transformation of physical into monetary equity. The additional X-world money was nobody’s liability - it wasn’t a debt of the State to anyone. But hang on - States throughout history have surely borrowed gold, especially in times of crisis. But it seems that what they borrowed was the stuff of gold as a physical asset. They didn't borrow accounting entries because those were private money. Prior to the start of the Bank of England, private bank money did not pass as State money. Privare accounting entries could no doubt be borrowed but they could not be merged with State money accounts since the two monies had different status.