Advice needed...customer claiming not received package
I need some advice. I've had a repeat customer come back and order a second poster (yay!), however today I have received a message telling me that she hasn't had the parcel. She's stating that it has been left in a safe place and the photo of that safe place is not her house, and she doesn't own the green bin it's been left behind on her property. I have checked the tracking from the first order and the photo provided shows an identical location for both of the deliveries. I know she has received the first order with no issue as she left a 5* review. I could just order a replacement, but I can't help but feel I'm being played. Do I go back with screenshots of the proof of delivery for both orders and challenge her? Or just take the hit and order a replacement and hope she doesn't request a refund next time??? What would you do?