LinkedIn Profile Review Guide: Green Flags vs Red Flags · AI for LinkedIn

Joe Apfelbaum

22d • LinkedIn Tips

LinkedIn Profile Review Guide: Green Flags vs Red Flags

Green Flags ✅

These indicators suggest a legitimate, professional profile:

Premium & Verification

Premium gold icon - Shows investment in professional networking
Verified icon - Platform has authenticated the user

Profile Completeness

Professional profile photo - Shows they take their presence seriously
Custom LinkedIn URL - Indicates they've optimized their profile
Background banner image - Demonstrates attention to visual branding
Complete education history - Shows transparency about background
Contact information with calendar link - Easy to connect and schedule

Activity & Engagement

Regular posting activity - Shows active professional engagement
Has recommendations from others - Social proof of work quality
Active in professional groups/communities - Engaged in their industry

Professional Details

Works for real company with logo and company page - Verifiable employment
Located in established market (like US) - Clear geographic context
Has meaningful connection network - Shows genuine professional relationships

Red Flags 🚩

These signs may indicate fake, incomplete, or unprofessional profiles:

Missing Basic Information

No profile photo - Major credibility issue
No last name shown - Suggests hiding identity
No country/location listed - Geographic anonymity
No background banner - Shows minimal effort

Incomplete Professional Info

No education history - Lack of background transparency
No current company or vague employment - Can't verify professional status
No recommendations - Lack of social proof
Zero connections - Suggests new or fake account

Limited Engagement

No posting activity - Inactive or dormant account
Not part of any professional groups - Limited industry engagement
Generic or incomplete job descriptions - Low effort profile

How to Use This Guide

When reviewing profiles:

Count the green flags vs red flags
Multiple red flags together are more concerning than isolated ones
Consider the person's career stage - new graduates may naturally have fewer connections
Look for patterns that suggest authenticity vs. those that suggest deception

Key principle: Legitimate professionals invest time in their LinkedIn presence, while fake or low-quality profiles often cut corners on basic profile elements.

20 comments