“Net impression” and writing compliant copy

Net impression is the overall feeling an ad gives you, no matter what words it actually uses. The FTC uses this idea to catch ads that trick people, even when the ad never tells a direct lie.

Imagine two different ads for the same course on how to write cold emails to get customers. In the first ad, the person filming is sitting inside a fancy Lamborghini with cool friends, talking about the course while showing off a rich lifestyle. In the second ad, the person sits at a plain desk and says something like: “I'll teach you everything I've learned over ten years, but you'll have to work hard. I can't promise you'll make money.”

Both ads might say the exact same things about the course. But the feeling you get is totally different. The first ad makes you think, “If I buy this course, I'll get a Lamborghini and live like a celebrity.” The second ad makes you think, “I'm buying a set of skills, and what I get out of it depends on how hard I work.” The FTC would have a problem with the first ad and be fine with the second, because the overall feeling matters, not just the exact words.

Net impression can be harder to spot than a flat-out lie, because it is more about the vibe of an ad than any one specific claim. But one of the most common problems is testimonials. If an ad shows one person's amazing result front and center, it can make you feel like that result is normal, even if the ad never says that.

The Skool newsletter below is a good example.

The subject line says: “$300k/month (no team + 95% profit).” Before the reader even opens the email, they already have a feeling. “This is what Skool does.” Then the email opens with Nick Saraev's story. He makes $300k a month with 95% profit, without a team. The email wraps up with this line: “The method is always the same... Create content → link to your skool → get members → make money.”

The email is not saying Nick got lucky, and it doesn't say Nick is an outlier among thousands of community owners on Skool. It is saying there is a method, it always works, and here it is. The NET IMPRESSION is that if ANYONE follow the steps, the money follows.

The email also features a screenshot of Nick's post, which includes the line: “It takes me approx 90min/day (earns me ~$7,000/hr!)” Skool did not write that, Nick did. But Skool chose to put it front and center. This creates the feeling that your time will be worth $7,000 an hour too. And nowhere in the email does it say that Nick's results are unusual, that he had a large YouTube audience before any of this, or that most Skool creators earn far less.

That is the net impression problem.

The email never lies. But everything in it–the subject line, the numbers, the word “always,” the screenshot, the simple three-step formula–adds up to one feeling. “Sign up and you can have this too.”

Here is a more compliant version of the email.

***

Subject line:

How Nick Saraev built a $300k/month Skool community by himself

Body:

Nick Saraev is one of the most successful community builders on Skool.

He recently won the Skool Games with a one-man community called Maker School.

It brings in around $300k a month with almost no overhead.

His results are not typical.

Most Skool creators earn much less, and what you make depends a lot on the size of your audience, your topic, and how much consistent work you put in.

But his approach is worth learning from.

Here is what he does:

He posts YouTube videos every week about his topic

He puts his Skool link in his YouTube bio

He hosts a live Q&A call for his members every week

People find his videos, click the link, and sign up for $184 a month.

It is a simple system, but it took years of becoming an expert and building an audience to get to this level.

When you start a Skool community, you get access to a network where people like Nick share exactly how they built theirs.

His post about this strategy has 4.5k likes and 5.5k comments, and it's one of the most helpful breakdowns on the platform.

Whether you are just getting started or already have an audience, Skool gives you the tools to build a community around what you know and charge for it.

Start for $9/month. 14-day free trial included.

CREATE YOUR SKOOL →

***

We've kept the numbers and Nick's inspiring story. But now the reader knows it is an exceptional case, not the average. That one shift changes the entire net impression from “sign up and get rich” to “here is what is possible if you put in the work.”

The ability to create compliant marketing is the most profitable skill in a copywriter's toolbox. You can save your clients millions of dollars in potential fines, and even save them from going out of business. Not only that but compliant copy brings in better customers. This has many downstream benefits. Like lower refund rates, therefore avoiding payment processor issues. And a more favourable brand image, which lowers CAC and increases LTV.

If you'd like to know more about creating compliant marketing, I have a paid course that shows you how to do exactly that. It's called “Copy Compliance Clinic.” You get access to it and 19 other courses, along with call-free coaching, when you upgrade to a Premium membership. It's $50/month.

https://www.skool.com/copywriting-launchpad/plans

9 comments