Crane Unloading from the Road: When the Loading Area Becomes the Hazard
A crane was unloading a bundle of reinforcement mesh directly from a lorry positioned on a roadway.
The photograph raises several serious concerns.
There is no obvious segregated loading/unloading zone, a car is immediately alongside the operation, and a worker is positioned on the edge of the lorry bed while the load is suspended (ready to fall).
There is also no clearly identifiable designated Slinger/Signaller visible controlling the lifting operation.
In UK practice, this combination would require careful lifting, logistics, traffic and work-at-height controls. HSE guidance says loading/unloading should generally take place away from passing traffic, pedestrians and people not involved in the operation.
What Went Wrong?
The photograph suggests several potential failures:
  • No obvious segregated loading/unloading area.
  • Road traffic appears extremely close to the lifting operation.
  • No clearly identifiable Slinger/Signaller controlling the crane.
  • A worker is positioned at the edge of the lorry bed.
  • No visible collective fall protection around the working position.
  • Suspended reinforcement mesh is close to personnel.
  • No obvious exclusion/drop zone around the load.
  • The lifting operation and road traffic appear to be occupying the same space.
HSE states that signallers directing cranes should be trained and competent and should work from a protected position.
The Lorry Bed Is a Work-at-Height Risk
One of the strongest lessons from this photograph isn’t actually the crane.
Look at the worker.
They appear to be sitting or slipping towards the edge of the vehicle while the load is being lifted.
If workers must access a lorry bed, the risk of falling must be controlled. HSE recommends eliminating the need to climb onto vehicles where possible and, where access remains necessary, considering suitable access, walkways, guardrails or other appropriate safeguards depending on the operation.
So the answer isn’t automatically “every lorry must have handrails.”
The correct principle is:
Prevent the fall, preferably through collective protection or by eliminating the need to work on the bed in the first place.
Roadside Lifting Changes the Risk
Once a delivery vehicle is being unloaded next to live traffic or members of the public, this is no longer simply:
Crane + load + slinger.
Now you have:
CRANE + LOAD + LORRY + WORKER AT HEIGHT + TRAFFIC + PUBLIC INTERFACE.
HSE guidance says loading areas should be in designated places, clear of passing traffic and pedestrians, and lifting plans should consider location and access. It also specifically recognises crossing a public road as a circumstance that can require greater supervision.
Slinger/Signaller vs Traffic Marshal
These are two different functions.
•The Slinger/Signaller controls the load and communicates with the crane operator.
•A Traffic Marshal/Banksman, where required by the traffic-management arrangement, controls or assists with vehicle movements.
One person should not simply be assumed to be performing both jobs while also trying to sling the load.
HSE distinguishes a banksman directing vehicles from a signaller directing crane movements.
Key Lessons Learned
Before a tower crane unloads a delivery, ask:
Where will the lorry park?
How will the area be segregated?
Who is the designated Slinger/Signaller?
How will workers access the load safely?
How will falls from the vehicle be prevented?
Where will traffic and pedestrians go?
What is the exclusion/drop zone?
If those questions haven’t been answered, the delivery is not ready to be lifted.
Safety Recommendations
  • Provide a planned and suitable unloading/loading area wherever practicable.
  • Segregate the lifting operation from traffic and pedestrians.
  • Establish an effective exclusion/drop zone.
  • Use a competent, clearly designated Slinger/Signaller.
  • Implement appropriate traffic management and trained marshals where required.
  • Eliminate unnecessary access onto the lorry bed.
  • Where access is necessary, provide suitable fall-prevention controls.
  • Keep personnel clear of suspended loads.
  • Coordinate deliveries with the lifting schedule before vehicles arrive.
  • If unloading must occur from a roadway, specifically plan the additional public/traffic interface rather than treating it as a normal site delivery.
HSE requires lifting operations to be properly planned, appropriately supervised and carried out safely, including suitable slinging/signalling arrangements and measures protecting people not involved in the lift.
Incident Source
Safety-learning case based on the supplied photograph. The photograph appears to show a crane unloading operation involving reinforcement mesh and a lorry positioned on a roadway. The location, country, traffic-management arrangements, competencies and circumstances have not been independently verified.
Regulatory Mapping – UK Learning
● LOLER Reg. 8 – Lifting operations must be properly planned by a competent person, appropriately supervised and carried out safely.
● Work at Height principles – The risk of workers falling from vehicles during loading/unloading must be eliminated or appropriately controlled.
● Workplace Transport – Loading/unloading areas should be separated from passing vehicles, pedestrians and uninvolved persons wherever practicable.
● CDM 2015 principles – Site logistics, vehicle movements and construction activities require effective planning, management and coordination.
● BS 7121 principles – Competent lifting personnel, safe signalling, exclusion arrangements and management of interfaces should form part of the planned lifting operation.
Key Point
The lift doesn’t start when the crane hook moves.
It starts when the delivery is planned.
Where will the lorry stop?
Where will traffic go?
Where will the Slinger stand?
How will the load be accessed safely?
Who controls the crane?
If the answer is simply:
“Park there and we’ll lift it off.”
Then the logistics have already failed before the crane even starts.
PLAN THE DELIVERY. SEGREGATE THE AREA. PROTECT THE WORKER. CONTROL THE LIFT.
Wolf Lifting Dynamics | www.wolflifting.uk | Case Study 152
0
0 comments
Vlad Lupu
4
Crane Unloading from the Road: When the Loading Area Becomes the Hazard
powered by
Safe Lifting
skool.com/wolf-lifting-dynamics-9548
This community shares real lifting case studies, consultancy insights, and site-proven lessons covering cranes, supervision, planning, and execution.
Build your own community
Bring people together around your passion and get paid.
Powered by