⚠️ Stop Building AI Checklists (Start Building AI Thinking)

Someone in our community posted: "Can you share your list of the best AI prompts?"

This question comes up constantly. People want the checklist. The template library. The prompt collection. The shortcuts.

We get why. Checklists feel productive. They feel like progress. But here's the problem: You're building the wrong thing.

Why prompt libraries fail

Collections of prompts seem useful until you actually try to use them. Then you discover that the prompt someone else wrote for their business doesn't quite fit yours. The tone is wrong, the context is different, or it's solving a slightly different problem than the one you actually have.

So you copy it, modify it, try it, get mediocre results, and go back searching for a better prompt. You're collecting prompts instead of solving problems.

We've seen this pattern repeatedly: Someone joins with a massive folder of "best AI prompts" collected from across the internet. They've spent hours organizing them by category. They're proud of their system.

Three months later? They admit they rarely use them. When they actually need AI for something, the prompts in their library never quite fit. They end up writing something new anyway.

What you're actually trying to accomplish

When you ask for a prompt library, what you really want is: "How do I get AI to help me with this specific thing I need to do?"

That's not a prompt question. That's a thinking question.

The skill isn't having the right prompt. The skill is being able to look at any task and figure out how AI might help with it. That's a completely different capability than maintaining a collection of templates.

The shift from checklist to thinking

Instead of asking "What's the best prompt for X?" start asking "What's the outcome I need and what does AI need to know to help me get there?"

Let's say you need to write an email to a client about a project delay. You could search for "client delay email prompt" and hope someone has already written one that fits your situation.

Or you could think: The client needs to know what happened, why it happened, what we're doing about it, and when they can expect resolution. They need to feel like we're in control and that this doesn't affect their end goals.

Tell AI that. Give the context about the specific project, the relationship with this client, and the tone you need to strike. You'll get better results than any generic prompt someone else wrote.

What actually transfers across situations

Here's what you can build that actually helps across different situations:

Understanding what AI needs: Context about who you are, what you're creating, and who it's for

The habit of iteration: Treating AI as a conversation, not a one-shot tool

Pattern recognition: Noticing where AI can help before the task becomes a problem

Outcome thinking: Focusing on what you need to accomplish rather than how to word the prompt

These are skills. They transfer. They improve with practice. They work for situations where no one has written a perfect prompt yet.

The prompt library trap

Collections of prompts create the illusion of preparation without actual capability. You feel ready because you have resources, but you're not building the skill to figure things out when your specific situation doesn't match any template.

It's like collecting recipes but never learning to cook. You can follow instructions, but you can't adapt when you're missing an ingredient or want to try something new.

What to build instead

Build examples. Every time you have a good AI interaction, save not just the prompt, but the thinking behind it.

"I needed to write a client proposal. I started by giving AI context about my business and this specific client's challenges. Then I asked for an outline. Then I had it expand on each section. Here's what worked and why."

That's reusable. Not the exact prompt, but the approach.

Build understanding. When something works well, ask yourself why. When something doesn't work, figure out what was missing. You're building judgment, not just a collection.

Build flexibility. Get comfortable figuring things out in the moment. The person who can adapt AI to new situations is more capable than the person with 1,000 saved prompts.

The uncomfortable question

Are you collecting prompts because it feels productive, or because you're avoiding the harder work of actually learning how to think alongside AI?

Collecting is easier than learning. Templates are easier than understanding. But only one of these builds real capability.

Where to start instead

Pick one thing you need to do this week. Don't search for a prompt. Open your AI tool and figure it out through conversation. Start with context, explain what you need, iterate until it works.

Save that process. Not just the final prompt, but the whole interaction and what you learned from it. Do this ten times and you'll have built more real capability than collecting 500 prompts ever could.

What's one task you're facing this week where you could build your AI thinking instead of searching for a template? Share it below.

19 comments