Jul 8 • 🏅Retention Strategies🏅
Why Your Best Tech Just Texted Me About a Job
Your best diagnostic tech is interviewing elsewhere right now.
Not because you don't pay well. Not because your shop isn't successful.
But because after 5 years of making you money, he still feels like "just another employee ID" – a number, not a member.
Here's the brutal reality:
While you're protecting your P&L like a state secret, shops down the street are revolutionizing how they treat technicians – not as employees, but as partners who deserve to know how the business really works.
Your tech sees the invoice for $150/hour labor but takes home $35. Without context, he assumes you're pocketing the difference.
Meanwhile, he's working in the dark, guessing at what matters, and eventually leaving for someone who treats him like a partner in serving your customers.
The cost of this secrecy is destroying shops:
- It takes 67,800 new techs annually just to replace those leaving the industry
- The average shop loses $47,000 in productivity for each tech that quits
- Tech turnover increased 23% last year alone (and it's accelerating)
- Every good technician has 8 automotive businesses trying to hire them
But here's what kills me...
You're already sharing 27% of gross revenue with your techs through wages. Yet they have no idea if they're helping the business succeed or bleeding it dry. They work blind, waste money unknowingly, and leave feeling undervalued.
The solution that's revolutionizing independent shops:
Schmidt Auto Care in Ohio was hemorrhaging techs until they implemented Open-Book Management with a gain-sharing formula.
Here's exactly what they did:
- Financial Transparency Boot Camp: Taught every tech how gross profit, effective labor rate, and parts margin drive the business
- Weekly Scoreboard Huddles: Published hours sold, comeback %, and margin data. Every tech forecasts their next week's production
- Gain-Sharing Formula: Pays quarterly bonuses from 15% of EBIT above baseline (prevents over-distribution while rewarding performance)
- Equity Participation: Created phantom stock vesting over 3-5 years for senior techs
The verified results:
- Schmidt now reports it's "harder for techs to leave us"
- Technicians see exactly how their work impacts profitability
- The team actively protects margins because it affects their bonuses
- Senior techs think like owners, not hourly employees
But it's not just Schmidt...
Springfield Remanufacturing grew 30-fold after going open-book.
Companies using this approach grow sales 1.66-2.21 percentage points faster than traditional shops.
Dave Kusa's shop has shared complete P&L statements with his team for years. He reports: "I remember when labor rates were around $50 an hour, technicians were getting paid $10 or $12 an hour, and I believed the owner was taking home the rest."
Now his techs understand exactly where every dollar goes – and they help optimize it.
Why this works when conventional approaches fail:
When technicians see the financial scoreboard, their behavior automatically optimizes the whole system.
They stop the waste.
They catch pricing errors.
They upsell legitimately.
They protect YOUR margins because those margins fund THEIR bonuses.
It transforms them from cost centers into profit partners.
Here's your implementation roadmap:
Week 1: Schedule a financial literacy workshop. Use simple examples: "When we bill $150/hour but pay you $35, here's where the other $115 goes..."
Week 2: Create your first scoreboard. Just three metrics: Hours Sold, Gross Profit %, Comeback Rate
Week 3: Announce the gain-sharing formula. Start conservative: 10% of monthly EBIT above your 3-month average
Week 4: Launch weekly huddles. 15 minutes every Monday. Show the numbers, celebrate wins, identify obstacles
Month 2: Add phantom equity for techs with 2+ years tenure. Even 1-2% vesting makes them think like owners
The shops implementing this aren't competing for techs anymore – they're building waiting lists of applicants.
Because technicians don't leave partners.
They leave employers.
Want to keep your best techs AND attract the ones your competitors can't afford to lose?
Stop guarding your numbers.
Start sharing your success.
P.S. That dealership offering $10,000 signing bonuses? They're spending $50,000+ per hire when you factor in recruitment, training, and lost productivity. You could implement open-book management for less than the cost of replacing one technician. The math is simple: transparency costs nothing but pays everything.
VERIFIED SOURCES (I verified each source to make sure AI didn't make stuff up for this post. DM me for the specific URL if you want to dive deeper):
¹ Competing with Dealerships PDF, Page 4: "you are a number, not a member" reference about dealership culture
² paste-2.txt: "The U.S. needs ≈ 67,800 new automotive service techs every year to replace retirees and leavers bls.gov"
³ Repair Shop Owner Comments (2).pdf: "Every 1 good technician has 8 automotive businesses looking to hire him/her"
⁴ Repair Shop Owner Comments (2).pdf: "Tech Cost = -27%" from profitability breakdown
⁵ paste-2.txt: Strategy 1 details about Schmidt Auto Care's implementation
⁶ paste-2.txt: "The owner reports it is now 'harder for techs to leave us'"
⁷ paste-2.txt: "Springfield Remanufacturing Corp. grew 30‑fold after adopting open‑book methods"
⁹ The Case for Financial Transparency with Your Auto Shop Employees - PartsTech: Dave Kusa's quote and transparency approach
2
2 comments
Why Your Best Tech Just Texted Me About a Job
skool.com/technicianfind
Proven templates, strategies, training and top-level networking to help independent auto repair shops hire quality staff faster.
Leaderboard (30-day)
1
+11
2
+8
3
+6
4
+4
5
+3
Powered by