Why Getting 100 Applications Might Be Worse Than Getting 10 (And How to Fix It)

The Good News and The Bad News

Last week, one of our clients called me frustrated as hell.

"Chris, the ads are working TOO well. My phone's ringing off the hook. I've got 50+ applications. But they're all jiffy lube refugees who think changing oil makes them a master tech."

Sound familiar?

Here's the thing - this is actually GOOD news. You've proven you can get attention. You've proven techs in your area are looking. You've proven your ads are visible.

Now we just need to dial in who RESPONDS to them.

The #1 Rule Most Shops Get Wrong

You can't improve what doesn't exist.

I see shops all the time trying to write the "perfect" ad with 15 requirements, ASE certifications, specific tool lists, and diagnostic experience minimums. Then they wonder why they get zero applications.

Here's the truth: Getting applications - even bad ones - is Step 1. You NEED that flow first. Once you've proven you can get 10-20 applications consistently, THEN you add the filters.

Think of it like tuning an engine. You don't start with the fine adjustments. You get it running first, then you dial it in.

The Sweet Spot Strategy That Actually Works

Here's exactly when and how to transition from quantity to quality:

Phase 1: Cast the Wide Net (Weeks 1-2)

Start with an ad that's 80% culture and benefits, 20% basic requirements.

Example headline: "Experienced Automotive Technician - $90K - $120K, No Weekends, Family Shop"

Why? You're testing the market. You're building momentum. You're getting your ad noticed.

Phase 2: Add Your First Filter (Week 3)

Once you're getting 10 - 20 applications per week, add ONE specific requirement to your headline.

Change to: "Diagnostic Technician - Must Know Scan Tools: $90K - $120K, No Weekends, Family Shop"

Watch what happens. You'll drop from 20 applications to maybe 12. But 3-4 of those 12 will actually be qualified.

Phase 3: Get Surgical (Week 4+)

Now that you know applications are flowing, get specific about exactly what you need.

Final version: "Master Diagnostic Tech – Lab Scope Pro Required: $90K - $120K, No Weekends, Family Shop" This might only get you 5-8 applications. But those 5-8? They're the real deal.

Real Shop, Real Results

Here's an actual before/after from one of our client shops:

Their Original Ad: Generic "hiring technicians" post

Result: 3 applications in 2 weeks (all unqualified)

Week 1 Revision: Added benefits and culture

Result: 47 applications (43 unqualified, 4 decent)

Week 3 Revision: Added "Must demonstrate diagnostic abilities"

Result: 18 applications (6 qualified, 3 excellent)

Week 5 Revision: Added specific tool requirements and "interview demo required"

Result: 8 applications (5 qualified, 2 hired)

See the pattern? You can't jump straight to Week 5. You need the momentum first.

Your Action Plan for This Week

If you're getting ZERO applications: Your ad is too demanding. Strip out 75% of your requirements. Focus on benefits and culture. Get the phone ringing first.
If you're getting 10-20 crap applications weekly: Perfect! You've got flow. Now add ONE specific technical requirement to your headline. Just one. See what happens.
If you're getting some qualified candidates: Time to get surgical. Add this line: "You'll be asked to demonstrate [specific skill] during the interview." Watch the pretenders disappear.

The Psychology Behind Why This Works

Parts changers apply to everything because they're desperate. They'll shotgun 50 applications hoping something sticks.

Real diagnostic techs? They're employed. They're selective. They only apply when they see something specific that speaks to their skills.

When your ad says "technician wanted," everyone applies. When your ad says "Must demonstrate lab scope proficiency," only the real pros even finish reading.

But remember - if you start with the lab scope requirement, even the pros might not see your ad because it's not getting enough traction in the algorithms.

One Critical Mistake to Avoid

Never - and I mean NEVER - put wages at the bottom or leave them vague.

If you're paying $90-120K for the right person, say it upfront. High wages in the headline attract both quantity AND quality. It's the one thing that works at every phase.

Bad: "Competitive pay based on experience" Good: "$90-120K for the right diagnostic tech"

The Bottom Line

Stop trying to write a perfectly detailed ad on Day 1.

Start with volume. Test your market. Get momentum. Then dial it in week by week until you're only talking to exactly who you want to hire.

It's not about getting fewer applications. It's about getting the RIGHT applications at the RIGHT time in your recruitment process.

Remember: You can always make a flowing river more narrow. You can't make a dry riverbed flow by adding more rocks.

Get the flow first.

Quality comes second.

This is the way.

2 comments

Technician Find Community

skool.com/technicianfind

Proven templates, strategies, training and top-level networking to help independent auto repair shops hire quality staff faster.

Done for you service information

Leaderboard (30-day)

+11