23d • 📣General discussion📣
The Tech Who Read Your 1-Star Reviews Before He Applied
He read every 1-star review the shop had.
Not the 5-stars. The 1-stars.
This was before he applied. Before he walked through the door. Before he ever met the team.
He went to Google. Pulled up the shop’s reviews. And started reading.
But he wasn’t reading the complaints.
He was reading the responses.
He wanted to know one thing.
What happens at this shop when a customer gets angry?
Does the owner throw the tech under the bus? Or does the owner have the team’s back?
He read every response. Then he applied.
She asked him why. He could’ve gone to the dealerships up the road. They were hiring. Some paid more.
His answer:
“I only came to work for you because I can see that you protect your technicians against the outside world.”
He didn’t pick the shop for the pay. Not the benefits. Not the sign-on bonus.
He picked it because of how the owner responded to a 1-star review.
Most shop owners think of Google reviews as a customer thing.
They’re also a recruiting tool.
The best technicians — the ones you actually want — are doing homework on you before they ever apply.
They’re Googling your shop name. Scrolling your reviews. Reading how you handle conflict in public.
These aren’t desperate candidates who blast their resume everywhere. These are employed techs with options. They’re choosy. And they’re looking for signals.
Your 1-star reviews are one of those signals.
Not the review itself. Your response to it.
Here’s what a good tech sees when they read your review responses:
Response #1: You throw your tech under the bus.
“We sincerely apologize. The technician responsible has been spoken to and this will not happen again.”
What a tech thinks reading that: If I make a mistake here, I’m getting publicly blamed. If a customer exaggerates, the owner sides with them automatically. Next.
Response #2: You get combative.
“Actually, you’re wrong. We did exactly what you asked for. Maybe if you maintained your vehicle properly this wouldn’t have happened.”
What a tech thinks: This owner can’t regulate their emotions when someone pushes back. Imagine what they’re like on a bad Tuesday when there’s a comeback and three waiters in the queue. Pass.
Response #3: You ignore it entirely.
No response. Three 1-star reviews sitting there. Months old.
What a tech thinks: They either don’t know these exist, or they don’t care. Either way, not a well-run shop. If they’re ignoring what people say about them publicly, what else are they ignoring?
Response #4: You stay professional and protect your team.
“We’re sorry to hear about your experience. We stand behind our work and our team, and we’d welcome the opportunity to make this right. Please give us a call.”
What a tech thinks: This shop has my back. They didn’t fold. They didn’t blame. They stayed steady. If something goes sideways here, I’m not getting thrown to the wolves.
That’s the response that gets applications.
You’re being evaluated right now by a tech you’ve never met.
Maybe they’re scrolling your Google reviews on their lunch break.
Maybe they’re checking your Facebook page after a rough day at their current shop.
Maybe they’ve been watching you for months.
I’ve watched this pattern play out over and over. A tech follows a shop’s Facebook for a year before they make a move. By the time they reach out, they already know everything about you.
How you treat your team in public. How you handle complaints. Whether you’re someone they’d trust on their worst day.
Your reviews, your Facebook, your website — they’re not just for customers. Technicians are watching too.
And you’re either passing the test or you’re not.
Here’s what I’d do this week.
Pull up your Google reviews. Read every negative one. But this time, read them through a technician’s eyes.
Ask yourself one question: if a good tech read this response, would they want to work here?
If you have unanswered negatives, answer them. Today.
If your responses blame your team, rewrite them.
If your responses get combative, soften them.
Every negative review is a chance to show a future technician who you really are. Don’t waste it.
This is bench-building work. You do it now so you’re not scrambling later.
By-the-way...
If you're currently short-staffed, or worried about becoming short-staffed in the future, we can help.
Comment HIRE if you need a tech now.
Comment BENCH if you want to build your pipeline before you need it.
I’ll point you in the right direction.
4
1 comment
The Tech Who Read Your 1-Star Reviews Before He Applied
skool.com/technicianfind
Proven templates, strategies, training and top-level networking to help independent auto repair shops hire quality staff faster.
Leaderboard (30-day)
1
+15
2
+11
3
+3
4
+3
5
+2
Powered by