Can students learn from teachers they don't like?
I read a social media post the other day that made me stop and think for a moment. I don't recall the exact quote but the educator posting was basically saying that children can only learn from teachers they like. At first glance, I thought, "Yeah, I can see her point there". But of course my brain didn't just stop there. I started thinking of all the teachers I learned from the most. I know for a fact that I did not like my 7th grade Social Studies teacher. But when I think back to her methods and what her students didn't like about her was that she taught them how to be organized, to make their notes visually effective, to not let their learning be distracted by chewing gum, or sitting wherever they chose in the class. Yes, she was strict and you didn't mess around in her class. I didn't like her but I did great in her class. I still organize my binders in a similar way to what she taught me. I color-code when teaching. In fact, it is a practice I rely on to help visual learners differentiate spelling patterns. I liked all of my other teachers, so maybe Ms. Allen was an exception to the rule. I loved school and even if I didn't like everything about a teacher's class, I knew they cared, and I think that's what matters more than being liked. If a child knows you care, they are open to learning from you and taking some risks. I agree that students engage more with teachers they like. But engagement doesn't equal learning does it? The class could engage in "fun Friday" games every week but that doesn't mean they are learning more than students in classes who don't. What do you think? Can students learn from teachers they don't like?