Responding to a student this evening who had a question on brands: I tend not to comment on 'brands' of essential oils. There would be no end to the 'argument' which would inevitably erupt. Instead, I choose to focus on teaching individuals about 'how to smell', how to develop their olfactory palette, how to smell essential oils from different companies (different brands) to gain awareness of how essential oils from the same plant can smell different from different companies (due to a number of factors: mostly, country of origin, but including time of harvest, weather patterns that years, etc. etc. etc.), how to 'listen' to an essential oil, etc.
We are also longtime advocates of the aromatic garden as I have long believed that smelling aromatics directly from living plant material helps re-awaken and expand our olfactory palette. By reconnecting our sense of smell with the actual plant, we are then able to more deeply 'interpret' the essential oil which may be in front of our nose.
I know and appreciate we cannot do this for all the different oils we have access to: for instance, I will most likely never smell fresh sandalwood being harvested or distilled (well, maybe) or copaiba... but smelling other plants with some similarities still expands my olfactory palette and allows me to evaluate each essential oil that I work with.
So for me, it's not about the brand... in fact, arguing about which brand is better is not the best or most productive approach because, as they say, 'beauty is in the eyes of the beholder', or in the case of essential oils 'authenticity' is in the 'brand name' or in the 'gc/ms report'. These two approaches remove the responsibility of the relationship between ourselves and the essential oils. Brand loyalty (although awesome), like an over-emphasis on gc/ms reports as the definitive guide to quality (not so awesome), places a 'road-block' in our path to being fully present with the essential oil, and in trusting (if one has developed their olfactory palette and acuity) our own organoleptic (sensory) perceptions and evaluations.
Anyhow, these are my thoughts on this matter. At the end of the day, no single brand has the best oils. There are many out there and each of us will choose the 'brand' that is right for us. I am not here to dictate what the best 'brand' is. For me, its not about the brand, its about the essential oils, its about our sense of smell and re-awakening it, re-empowering our ability to 'listen' and hear their (the essential oils) messages, quality, etc. etc. etc. :-
Image: Monarda didyma growing in our gardens.