Does you mom know what you’re doing?

Could I write an email to my mom from somebody else’s address and be about 80% sure she would open it?

Yes.

Not because I am a copywriter. Because I know her. What she worries about. What she ignores. Which line she would never delete, even from a stranger.

If you know a person that well, the open is not a mystery. It is a prediction.

People don’t hate cold email. They hate mail that has nothing to do with them.

Wrong industry. Wrong title. Wrong problem. Wrong moment. A message that proves you never looked at them — only at a row in a CSV.

The inbox is not offended by outreach. It is offended by irrelevance.

Stop testing your way out of a bad list.

Subject lines, spintax, offer tests, new angles every week. None of that is useless. A lot of it is compensation for contacts you don’t actually understand.

Most people in this school treat copy as the variable and the audience as the constant. Flip it. The audience is the variable. The copy is the output.

I am not saying never test. Measure what you send. But if your first question is “what subject line should I test?” instead of “do I actually know these people?” you are optimizing the wrapper and ignoring the package.

If you segment the data well enough, the open should feel closer to a forecast than a gamble.

The mom test, applied

Knowing them is not first name and company. That is mail merge.

Can you answer this without guessing: who they are, what has to be true this week for your email to matter, the language they use with peers, and why they would open this from a stranger?

Demographics get you in the zip code. Role, trigger, timing, and language get you in the house.

If two contacts share a title but not a problem, they do not belong in the same send. That is not a copy problem. That is a segmentation problem wearing a copy costume.

Do this before you write

• If you cannot explain who they are in one sentence, you do not know them yet.

• Split until the segment is obvious. “SaaS founders” is not a segment.

• Write to one named human. Send it to the rest only if it still fits.

• If you cannot predict why they would open it, do not send it. Go back to the data.

Testing is how you refine a message you already had a reason to send. It is not how you discover who you are talking to.

The question

Strip away the tools and the tests. One human. One email. An address they don’t know. Would you be 80% sure they’d open it?

If the answer is no, do not write more copy. Go understand the contact.

That is why people are tired of cold email. And that is how you stop being the email they are tired of.

— Sasha

7 comments