💎 Why a Lifetime Subscription Model Could Actually Work (on Skool)

Aug 11 (edited) • 💎 Promote by Educating

Hey everybody, I just watched this video that talks about lifetime deals, and I was thinking how this would also applies to our Skool communities. I might actually use these insights in the future (after I test out and see how the subscription model works).

➡️ Here's the summary:

"I Made +$160K Selling SaaS Lifetime Deals"

⚫ The Bold Move That Changed Everything

A SaaS founder broke the conventional wisdom by offering lifetime deals (LTDs) for his products, resulting in a 56% increase in revenue despite widespread warnings from other founders that this approach is "unsustainable" and "a race to the bottom."

⚫ The Success Story

Founders Deck Bundle: A lifetime offer providing access to 4 SaaS tools (social media, AI support, link tracking, and graphics design) plus 2 future tools for a one-time payment of $799.

⚫ Results so far:

~230 buyers
$160,000+ in total revenue
Net positive impact on subscriber base (+5 new subscribers)

Previous Experience with Lifetime Deals

Feed Hive on AppSumo (2022): Top 5 bestselling product, $300,000+ revenue, 5,000+ lifetime users
Link Drip pre-sales: Many users still active 3 years later
Extensive data and insights from thousands of lifetime deal customers

⚫ Common Objections Debunked

Myth 1: "Lifetime users never churn"

Reality: Lifetime users DO churn for the same reasons as subscribers:

Business closure
Outgrowing the solution
Switching to agencies with different tools
Moving to new solutions

Key insight: When accounting for "Jonathan users" (buyers who never actually use the product), lifetime users often churn faster than subscribers.

Myth 2: "It's financially unsustainable"

Reality: With proper pricing, it takes 37 years before Founders Deck users would become net negative investments.

Myth 3: "It will destroy your subscriber base"

Reality: Only 4.5% of Founders Deck buyers were existing subscribers, and the campaign actually netted +5 new subscribers overall.

⚫ The 3 Essential Rules for Successful Lifetime Deals

1. Set a Relatively High Price Point

$799 for Founders Deck (4 tools + 2 future tools)
Creates sufficient buffer before reaching break-even point
Reduces cannibalization of existing subscriber base
Makes the math work long-term

2. Keep Costs Low with Smart Product Design

Fully self-served products
No demo calls, sales meetings, or manual onboarding
No dedicated customer success agents
Extensive guides, tutorials, and videos for self-help
Simple but specialized tools
Tight cost control and operational efficiency

3. Build a Strong Public Reputation

Be the public face of your company
Active presence on social media, YouTube, email
Demonstrate responsibility and trustworthiness
Show you won't just "pump and dump"
Build trust through transparency and consistent communication

⚫ The Trust Problem

Why skepticism exists:

Bad actors have exploited LTD marketplaces (AppSumo, PitchGround, DealMirror)
"Pump and dump" schemes where founders overpromise and shut down quickly
Well-intentioned founders who underpriced AI-heavy tools and went bankrupt

Solution: Public accountability and reputation building are essential.

⚫ Key Takeaways

Lifetime deals can be sustainable when priced correctly and managed properly
User behavior is similar between lifetime and subscription customers
High price points protect against cannibalization and ensure profitability
Low-touch, self-served products are essential for healthy unit economics
Founder reputation and transparency are critical for buyer trust
Conservative financial modeling prevents the common pitfalls

⚫ Bottom Line

Rather than blindly rejecting lifetime deals, SaaS founders should consider them as a viable revenue strategy - but only with proper pricing, cost control, and reputation building in place. The key is making the math work while maintaining trust with customers.

---------------------------------------------------------

Starting a new community? Skool has a 14 day free trial and then $9/m - Please consider using my referral link to support this community. Thank you 🙏

7 comments