Thoughtful Thursday · Word Crafters

🔥

Thoughtful Thursday

The October Invite‑a‑thon — Day 4: Design Your Template (Make It Look Like You)

We need to talk about the mistake that almost every author makes the first time they open an email template builder.

You log in, click "Templates," and your email provider proudly displays fifty gorgeous, pre-made designs. They look like glossy department-store catalogs. Multi-column grids, flashing discount banners, coupon codes, social media badges, three different button styles, and hero images the size of billboards.

It looks professional. It looks like marketing. So you pick one, spend an hour trying to cram your author updates into a layout built for a shoe company, and by the time you're done, you're sweating, frustrated, and dreading having to do it ever again.

Here is the truth: readers do not want a sales flyer from an author.

When a reader opens an email from you, they want it to feel like a letter from a person whose stories they enjoy. The moment an email looks like a commercial brochure, two bad things happen simultaneously: the reader's brain tunes out the text as advertising, and Gmail's algorithm takes one look at the heavy image-to-text ratio and dumps your message straight into the Promotions tab—or worse, the spam folder.

Today's mission is about radical simplification. We're going to build a clean, bulletproof, reusable template in ten minutes. One that looks personal, loads instantly on every phone, protects your deliverability, and makes writing your weekly email as frictionless as typing a note to a friend.

The Universal Anatomy of an Author Newsletter

Whether you're using MailerLite, ConvertKit, beehiiv, Substack, or an old Mailchimp account you dusted off on Monday, every great author email relies on the exact same four elements.

You can build this anywhere because it requires almost no code and zero graphic design skills:

1. The Minimal Header (Optional, but Keep It Lean) You don't need a massive graphic banner that eats up the top half of a phone screen. If you have a clean author logo or a simple bookish header, keep it small—no taller than 100 to 150 pixels. If you don't have one, plain text with your author name or your newsletter's title in a slightly bolder font works just as well. The goal is instant recognition, not visual noise.

2. The Reading Column (Single Column Only) Never use two-column layouts for writing updates. They break awkwardly on mobile devices, and nobody reads a letter in side-by-side boxes. Set your email width to standard (usually 600px), pick a clean, readable font—Georgia, Merriweather, or a clean sans-serif like Arial or Helvetica—and set your font size to 16px or 18px with comfortable line spacing (1.5). Dark charcoal text on a pure white or very soft off-white background. Make it easy on tired eyes.

3. The Accent Color (Pick Just One) Consistency beats flash. Choose one color that matches your genre or your website—a deep navy, a forest green, a warm burgundy, or slate—and use it exclusively for your links and your action buttons. When everything is colorful, nothing stands out. When the entire email is clean text and there's a single, sharp colored button pointing to your book or blog, the reader knows exactly where to look.

4. The Human Sign-off and Legal Footer At the bottom of your text, include a warm, standard sign-off: your name, maybe a small author photo or a digital signature graphic if you like that touch, followed by a soft P.S. block. Below that sits your required legal footer—your physical mailing address (or PO Box/business mailing service) and the unsubscribe button. Every platform handles the footer automatically for compliance, so you just need to make sure the font color isn't completely washed out.

Building It in MailerLite (Click-by-Click)

If you're following along on MailerLite's free plan, here's how to lock this container down in under ten minutes so it's ready every time you sit down to write:

Open the Template Area: From your MailerLite dashboard, click Campaigns, select the Templates tab at the top, and click Create template.
Choose the Drag-and-Drop Editor: Name your template something sensible—like "Weekly Author Letter"—and choose the interactive Drag-and-drop editor.
Strip the Junk: MailerLite will load a default layout with logos, image galleries, and placeholder cards. Click the little trash can icon on every single block until you have only three items left:

One header block at the very top (image or plain text).
One simple text block in the middle.
The required footer block at the bottom.

Tune the Global Styles: On the right-hand settings panel, click the Settings tab. Set your font to your preferred reading face (Georgia or Helvetica are bulletproof), set the body text size to 16px or 18px, set text color to #222222 (soft black), and pick your single button color under the Button settings.
Drop in Placeholder Text: In your text block, type out a quick skeleton:

Hey [Name],

[Your weekly story, writing update, or book recommendation goes here.]

Talk soon, Michael

P.S. [A quick link to your book, magnet, or a question for the comments.]

Save and Exit: Click the green Done editing button in the top right.

That's your chassis.

Whenever you send an email from now on, you don't start with a blank screen or a complicated design puzzle. You simply duplicate that saved template, overwrite the placeholder text with this week's story, and hit schedule.

If You're on Another Platform

If you're using Substack, beehiiv, or ConvertKit, your life is even easier. Those platforms were engineered around written letters rather than ecommerce catalogs.

ConvertKit: Go to Settings → Email Templates, choose the simple "Text" or "Modern" starting point, pick your font and link color, and save it.
Substack or beehiiv: Your template is essentially already built by default. Spend five minutes in your Publication Settings verifying your font choices and uploading a clean wordmark or author portrait.

The rule holds across every platform: if it looks like an essay or a personal letter, you're winning. If it looks like a Cyber Monday ad from an electronics retailer, strip it down.

Today's Mission (Under 10 Minutes)

Today isn't about drafting your next broadcast—we do that tomorrow. Today is about building the vessel so tomorrow's writing takes zero tech headache.

☐ Pick your body font (Georgia or a clean sans-serif) and one single accent color.

☐ Open your email platform's template builder.

☐ Build a clean, single-column layout: optional minimal header, readable text box, human sign-off, legal footer. Delete every other image gallery, spacer, and multi-column block.

☐ Send a test email to your own inbox and open it on your phone. Can you read it easily without zooming in? Does it feel like a letter from a friend?

☐ Save it as your default template. The October Invite‑a‑thon — Day 4: Design Your Template (Make It Look Like You)

☐ Post your receipt in the Skool thread—drop a screenshot of your clean template on mobile, or tell us which font/color pairing you locked in.

Once that container is saved, the friction vanishes. Tomorrow morning, you won't be wrestling with image paddings or broken layouts.

Tomorrow, we write 150 words, celebrate the week, and actually press send.

KEEL's Note: "A bloated template isn't just an aesthetic mistake; it's an engineering liability. Every unnecessary image tag and nested table increases the raw HTML weight of your message. Gmail automatically clips emails larger than 102 kilobytes, hiding your footer and your unsubscribe link behind an ugly 'View entire message' button. Keep the template lean, keep it under 50KB, and your deliverability takes care of itself."

PAIGE's Note: "When I get an email from an author with three different fonts, two banners, and four buy buttons, I immediately feel like an audience member being sold to. When I get an email that's just clean text with white space and a good sign-off, it feels intimate. It feels like they wrote it to me. Keep it simple. That's what makes people hit reply."

********

Tomorrow: Day 5 — The Finale. Drafting your 150-word broadcast, conquering the send-button hesitation, and launching your list into the rest of October. See you in the feed.

4 comments

Thoughtful Thursday