Activity
Mon
Wed
Fri
Sun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
Dec
Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
What is this?
Less
More

Memberships

The Writer's Forge

602 members • $7/month

253 contributions to The Writer's Forge
You have an eye for film — rip this apart and help us remove the AI slop
We showed Tom, my business coach, a short AI-made video we put together last night to get his feedback since he has attempted. It was rushed, but his main point was clear: the work has to be good enough that people don’t judge it as “impressive for AI”. it has to just work as a video. I'm not sure if I'm hiding behind "choosing my preferred style of art" to justify NOT being good enough. I’d love more eyes on it from people who understand film, story, pacing, visuals, and taste. Please rip it apart: - Specifically, what makes it feel like AI slop? I dont know, what I dont know. - Is this a quality video production(pacing, transitions, movement, etct) issue or is AI slop killing the video production itself? - What would make it feel more cinematic? Attached below. Honest feedback is more useful than encouragement. 🤟💪 especially you @David Stem @Chad Desrochers
You have an eye for film — rip this apart and help us remove the AI slop
1 like • 6h
thanks for this and the notes @Chad Desrochers and @Jason Smith - turns out arc pan is among the hardest to pull off in ai /// my first thought was read blink of an eye by Walter mitch who added apocalypse now, however after asking Claude, what Claude thought about that it came up with these notes.: “For AI-generated proof of concept work specifically, there’s no single book written for that use case yet — it’s too new. But the craft underneath it is the same. Here are the best sources depending on what angle you need: For the editing fundamentals Jason was describing In the Blink of an Eye by Walter Murch is the one. Short, readable, written by the editor of Apocalypse Now. Covers rhythm, emotion, and why cuts work or don’t — exactly the “suspension of disbelief / flow” territory Jason was gesturing at. For visual storytelling and shot grammar The Visual Story by Bruce Block. This is the one that explains why a string of close-ups feels wrong — it’s about contrast, space, and how the eye reads sequences. Very applicable to selecting and ordering AI-generated shots. For story structure underlying the footage Story by Robert McKee if you want the full theory. Save the Cat by Blake Snyder if you want something faster and more practical — closer to what Chad was describing about arrival/chaos/transformation arcs. The honest reality For AI proof-of-concept reels the actual gap isn’t editing theory — it’s shot selection and continuity, because AI generation gives you inconsistent lighting, character drift, and spatial incoherence that no editing technique fully fixes. Murch will teach you when to cut. The harder problem is having enough good material to cut between. In the Blink of an Eye first. Everything else builds from there.
0 likes • 6h
and having an experienced editor look 👀 Other titles to search • “Lookbook editor” • “Director’s reel editor” • “Pitch package editor” • “Treatment video editor” These people work at the intersection of advertising and development.
Today’s Premium Coffee & Coaching call was exactly what The Writer’s Forge is built for.
Ian brought in pages from Kilo, his new dive/cartel/family-business thriller. He walked us through how the idea started as messy notes from a real diving story, became a scriptment, and is now turning into actual pages. Then the group jumped in and read it out loud. Chad read Kyle. Elliot Moss read Becks. David Hinnebusch narrated. Pia, Lena, Chris, Thia, and others stepped into roles and helped bring the pages to life. We also heard from Tim Elliott about Son of the 11th Hour, the faith-based independent film he’s executive producing, and then read from his JFK/Lee Harvey Oswald script-in-progress. That’s what Premium is. Real writers, pages and project. Not theory or vague encouragement or "writers" talking about "writing"... some day. Members are bringing in scripts, testing scenes, hearing their work out loud, getting feedback, and helping each other make the pages better while the work is still alive. If you’re a Standard Member and you want to be part of these live coaching calls, table reads, and work-in-progress sessions, upgrade to Premium. This is where the work gets real. Premium Membership available here: https://www.skool.com/the-writers-forge/plans
Today’s Premium Coffee & Coaching call was exactly what The Writer’s Forge is built for.
1 like • 1d
thank you @Ian Campbell and @T.w. Elliott for the inspiration! good as it gets! thank you all! my Duran Duran meets #jfkfetalsyndrome (my main character’s malaise true story!)
what is your favorite word?
Mine today is “treehouse” Anyway I watched this today and it really touched my soul: https://youtu.be/MC8Z4cUc6YA “STOP NOT WRITING” ✍️
1 like • 2d
@Jason Smith full disclosure I did check to make sure all those will and Ariel Durant books were in order and complete 😝
"Pull my string! The BIZ TALK is TODAY!": WED, MAY 27, 10am PST
JOIN US TODAY as we welcome our very own "The Writer's Forge Member CHRIS DYER, ACTOR, WRITER & SNAPPY DRESSER to our Wednesday business talk where he will discuss everything Vertical, Micro Drama and he promises not to trigger anyone with AI talk (Insert Evil Laugh Here). (Chris' Internal Voice): "Keep it professional Chris. Oh be quiet. Anyways..." MICRO DRAMAS & THE FUTURE OF STORYTELLING A Live Workshop with Chris Dyer What if Vertical Dramas/Micro Series weren’t just “TikTok content”… but a strategic tool to get your REAL Film/TV projects seen, built, financed, or even discovered? In this live workshop, we’ll break down the rapidly growing world of Vertical Storytelling — from platforms like ReelShort and DramaBox to the larger creator economy shift happening across TikTok, YouTube, and beyond. We’ll cover: - Why vertical dramas are exploding globally - How mobile-first storytelling changes writing structure - Hook + cliffhanger engineering - Why audiences get addicted to these formats - The difference between traditional TV writing vs vertical pacing - How creators are using verticals as proof-of-concept IP - AI, creator-owned entertainment, and the future of Hollywood - How verticals could help writers get visibility, build leverage, and create opportunities for their “real” projects - Production, monetization, and viral marketing strategies - A live mini writer’s room + working session where you’ll start building your own concept This is NOT a “TikTok is the future, cinema is dead” lecture. It’s a practical, honest, and slightly rebellious conversation about where storytelling, audience behavior, and creator leverage may be heading next. Whether you’re curious, skeptical, fascinated, terrified, or convinced verticals are destroying civilization… this workshop is designed to challenge your perspective and give you actionable tools for the modern entertainment landscape. Because the future may belong to creators who stop waiting for permission.
0 likes • 3d
can’t wait!
0 likes • 3d
@Chris Dyer pork chops and apple sauce
Why the "Why" matters.
I was involved in facilitating a pitch and/or new idea synopsis event, and in retrospect, the event was a lesson in clarity. Though all the writers had unique ideas, there were loglines that each sentence felt like a different story, synopses that were unclear about what story they were going to tell, and the pitch was not prepared and meandered. It was annoying, and that judgment of them by me reflected directly back at me because I know I've done and will do the same thing in the future. I certainly have my daily/weekly moments where I've written something that doesn't add to the story, or it violates the rules of the world I created. So I've learned to stop and ask, "Why?" or "Does this make sense, and "What are the ripple effects on the story as a whole?" I will always miss things that readers will find for me, and that's the ultimate value of bringing your pages to the Premium Calls of having David Stem and the community ask you questions or point out things that might need to be addressed, or those things that you've done are amazing. Developing the skill of asking myself, does this make sense, or is it just pretty fluff that I'm adding in for spectacle, or is it me just adding pages instead of adding story is golden skill I'm constantly trying to develop. Does any of this resonate with you? Asking "why" strips away superficial plot points to reveal character motivation. If a character chooses without a clear internal or external "why," the audience immediately disconnects."-- John Musker
Why the "Why" matters.
0 likes • 3d
Adrian Tchaikovsky https://youtu.be/LO0qHnhpkDs seems to believe the world building makes the why and https://youtu.be/BmpdIEITRsY
1-10 of 253
David Hinnebusch
6
1,304points to level up
@david-hinnebusch-3898
Los Angeles based painter making a graphic novel- in Montréal a lot for family :)

Active 3h ago
Joined Nov 15, 2025
ENTP
Montreal and Santa Monica
Powered by