Activity
Mon
Wed
Fri
Sun
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
Dec
Jan
Feb
Mar
What is this?
Less
More

Memberships

Brotherhood Of Scent

8.7k members • Free

Real Men Real Style Community

13.5k members • Free

4938 contributions to Brotherhood Of Scent
Why I’ve Quit Dupes (ME and otherwise)
Buckle up brethren, this one could get spicy. Be respectful but do not feel like you need to hold back. https://youtu.be/L12y8gYANCQ?si=usjLr5CgbmdEkZaX I recently watched this video talking about stepping away from the world of fragrance dupes, and it hit on something I think a lot of us eventually run into if we stay in the hobby long enough. Early on, I actually bought quite a few of them myself. At the time it made sense, I wanted to quickly experience a lot of different scent profiles and build a frame of reference for my nose. Instead of dropping serious money on niche bottles right away, picking up cheaper fragrances allowed me to explore different styles: ambroxan-heavy modern masculines, blues, gourmands, musks, orientals, etc. In that phase, they served a purpose. But over time I’ve become much more skeptical of the hype around them. One thing that has really started to bother me is the influencer habit of assigning percentage equivalence to the original fragrance. You’ll hear things like “90% of the original” or “95% the same.” In reality, fragrance doesn’t really work like that. A dupe might capture the general direction of a scent profile, but it rarely captures the full balance, texture, and refinement of the original. Once you’ve smelled enough fragrances, and you actually spend multiple wearings with the originals, those differences start to become pretty obvious. And frankly, they’re often not nearly as good as they’re hyped up to be. You may find a few here and there that you truly enjoy or prefer, but overall, it’s just not there. Another issue that creeps up over time is simple collection fatigue. When your collection is small, grabbing a few inexpensive bottles feels harmless. But once you get past roughly 25–30 bottles, those dupes start to feel like clutter more than anything else. They take up space, rarely get worn, and you realize there’s no realistic way you’re ever going to go through all that juice anyway.
🔥
3 likes • 2d
@Dovi Rubelow I’m way beyond 20-35 of the things I truly want in my collection. I’ll declutter some, but definitely have no intention of adding anything but what I feel is great quality moving forward.
🔥
3 likes • 6h
@Erick Tai you have a good point. I mainly wanted to share my experience and the reasons behind my current position. I have more than enough frags to last me the rest of my life, but I still want to explore and sample and buy. Not buying clones also helps with that by somewhat keeping my volume in check. It allows me to sell or trade and not just continuously balloon the size of the collection without a clear way to offload things I fall out of love with. Dupes and clones offer little to no resale or trade value. Again, just my experience and opinion.
Legend+ by ath
Today’s ATH is Legend+. A fresh mass appealing frag that’s great for all seasons. I feel it can shine anywhere except brutal cold. Although it’s not like I work outdoors so honestly 4 season frag for me. Today is a beautiful 65 deg and sunny here. Perfect for this one. As with all the ATH I have, the quality of this is what pulls me in. Work safe and enjoyable. Longevity is good at about 6-7 hours. Projection isn’t offensive and not blowing doors off while still filling a smaller office setting. This is an odd one for me though in that it’s outside my usual jam. What pulls me into it is the high quality that Aaron produces.
Legend+ by ath
🔥
0 likes • 6h
@Paul Bartnicki I would definitely classify ATH as indie in terms of his business model and his willingness to be “creative” in his fragrance names. His packaging, branding, and most popular scent profiles suggest niche. Indie is a subset of niche so I think it fits.
SOTD Rayhaan Aquatica
A beautiful summer scent that opens up with a nice dose of citrus lime, some coconut, bergamot, and mandarin before settling on tonka bean, musk, rum, and one of my recent favorites patchouli. This is one fragrance and I’m gonna be wearing a lot during the warmer months. Here on Long Island it’s gotten near 60° and I’m pushing and praying for that warm weather to come!
SOTD Rayhaan Aquatica
🔥
2 likes • 6h
@Eric U brother you gotta go get your nose on the OG.
The Birthday SOTD “KxxT”
It’s my birthday, and I started the day surrounded by mesquite smoke. I’ve been busy at the pit with five racks of ribs and three Boston butts. Now that I’m cleaned up and ready for the family to arrive, I didn't want to leave that smoky vibe behind entirely. I decided to go with K@$T by Aaron Terence Hughes. It’s got that perfect blend of smoke and leather, balanced out with just the right touch of sweetness from the fruit. I have to keep this short since the guests are pulling up. Thanks for the well wishes, everyone—stay smelling great!
The Birthday SOTD “KxxT”
🔥
0 likes • 6h
Happy Birthday K*nt
SOTD: Hellenist - Les Dieux aux Bains
Picked up a 10ml decant of Les Dieux aux Bains by Hellenist after seeing it absolutely blow up across the Facebook groups and wanted to see what the hype was about. On paper, it honestly threw me off a bit. Very much comes across like you just did a full load of laundry with lemon detergent and doubled up on lemon dryer sheets; super clean, almost too clean, borderline sharp. But on skin it’s a completely different story. That initial blast settles down pretty quickly and what’s left is this really airy, diffusive lemon. It loses that harsh “cleaning product” edge and turns into something much more wearable. It’s light, breezy, and almost transparent. Feels like a soft lemon haze rather than a dense citrus bomb. Put this to its first test in Arizona’s March heat wave (first 100° day), both outside and in the gym, and honestly, this is where it clicked. Light, citrusy, and perfectly suited for this kind of dry heat. It stayed refreshing without ever getting cloying or heavy. Performance was right where you’d expect for this scent profile: about 4 hours of solid presence, then another 2–3 hours hanging closer to the skin. For an airy citrus like this, that’s pretty much ideal. Early verdict: hype makes sense if you understand what you’re getting. This isn’t a powerhouse; it’s a clean, effortless, hot-weather reach that just works. Is it full bottle worthy? Yet to be determined. Is it worth sampling? Definitely. Is it worth a 5-10ml decant? If you live in a warm climate, yes. I’d double up and say definitely if you already have a big collection but somehow can never seem to get enough freshies. And yes, it has a pretty cheeky looking bottle.
SOTD: Hellenist - Les Dieux aux Bains
🔥
1 like • 2d
@John Hart definitely grab a sample or a decant if you’re in a warmer climate.
🔥
2 likes • 2d
@Raul Olveda we have enough in our collections that unless it’s a smash and put 15 ml away in a summer, a decant is more than enough.
1-10 of 4,938
🔥
@ben-e-1936
Just a man on a mission to feel good, look good, and smell good!

Active 6h ago
Joined Jan 29, 2025
Arizona
Powered by