The loan amount was the problem — not the property, not the credit, not the value… This is a live file from my desk, shared the way we always do it here: real numbers from the record, no borrower name, no street address, and every lender anonymized. What follows are quotes received on one specific file — not offers to anyone, not market rates, and not a promise that any of them funds. The lesson inside it is one every investor in this community will use. 🗂️ On My Desk — The Deal Sherman Oaks, California. A single-family investment property held in an LLC, appraised at $3,042,000 — the appraisal covers both parcels on this file. The existing loan is $1,000,000 at 10.25%. The ask is a $1,000,000 rate-and-term refinance to pay it off — roughly 33% of the appraised value. On paper, this should have been the easiest file of the month. Here is the catch. The property is currently vacant. The plan is to lease it at $5,500 a month and deliver an executed lease. But the appraisal's own rent schedule reconciled market rent at $4,500 a month — and this whole loan turns on which of those two rents underwriting believes. 🧮 The Math — Where 0.76 Becomes 0.69 The first lender priced this file at a 7.375% working rate, interest-only: a $6,146 monthly payment, plus $937 a month in taxes and $132 a month in insurance, for a PITIA of $7,215. At the planned $5,500 rent, that is a DSCR of about 0.76. Then the rule that changed everything arrived. On this lender's programs, a DSCR under 1.0 cannot go interest-only — it is 30-year amortizing only. Three of its programs set a 0.80 minimum DSCR, so before submission the account executive moved this file into the one program whose floor is 0.75. The file went to underwriting on November 9, with that program's pricing still to be revisited — which is why I call 7.375% a working rate, not a promise. Run the same loan amortizing at that working rate and the picture moves: principal and interest of $6,906.75, a PITIA of $7,975.87, and a DSCR of 0.69 at $5,500 in rent — or 0.56 at the appraiser's $4,500.