One thing we noticed pretty fast: the data is never as clean as you think. Different newsletters structure things in wildly different ways… sometimes even the same creator changes formatting issue to issue.
Here’s a tiny snippet from one of our comparisons (blurred names for privacy):
(check the screenshots)
This is the kind of stuff we’re tracking per issue:
- Section count (Issues with ~5 sections performed better on average than issues with 9–10, regardless of how long they were)
- Emoji usage (One issue we saw literally had 36 emojis 😭)
- What the issue is trying to do (inform, entertain, persuade, etc.)
- Recurring creative formats
- How consistent a creator actually is from week to week
If you run a newsletter, I’m curious:
Which patterns do YOU notice in your niche that other people might miss?
Always love hearing how different creators think about structure and storytelling.