Mar 29 • Sports Performance Zone!
We’ve known how to stop ACL tears for 20 years, so why is the rate for girls still 8x higher than boys?
The NYT dropped a massive deep dive on the 'ACL Epidemic.' Here are the 3 things every parent in this group needs to know about , fatigue, hormones, and the 'FIFA 11+' program..."
Summarized
"Why Are So Many Teen Girls Still Tearing Their A.C.L.s?" by Craig Welch (published Feb 26, 2026), is a deep dive into what is being called a "public health crisis" in youth sports.|
The "Why" Behind the Crisis: Key Findings
1. The "Still" Problem Researchers have known about this disparity since the 1990s, yet the injury rates for girls have not improved in over 20 years. In fact, in sports like soccer, girls are 2 to 8 times more likely to tear an ACL than boys.|
2. The Devastating "Double"
- The Year-Long Gap: For a high school athlete, an ACL tear isn't just a physical injury; it's a social and emotional "erasure" from their community for 9–12 months.
- The Re-Injury Trap: Girls have up to a 1 in 3 chance of tearing an ACL a second time within a year of returning to their sport.
3. It’s Not Just Anatomy (The Social Gap) The article moves past the old "wide hips" theory and looks at how we raise athletes:
- The Strength Deficit: Boys are often encouraged to lift weights and build muscle early on. Girls are frequently trained "as if they are boys" but without the foundational strength training that protects the joints.
- Movement Literacy: Modern kids are more sedentary than previous generations. They lack the "movement literacy" (jumping, landing, and falling correctly) that used to be developed through free play.
4. The Biomechanical Differences
- Quad Dominance: Females tend to be "quad dominant," meaning their hamstrings aren't strong enough to counterbalance the pull on the knee during a hard plant.
- Valgus Collapse: Girls are more likely to land with their knees caving inward—a high-risk position for a non-contact tear.
5. The Hormonal Factor The article highlights emerging research on the menstrual cycle. Fluctuations in estrogen and progesterone (particularly in the pre-ovulatory phase) can increase ligament laxity and decrease neuromuscular reaction time.
The "Unblocker": What We Can Actually Do
The most frustrating finding of the article is that we already have the cure, but we aren't using it.
- The FIFA 11+ Program: This 15-minute neuromuscular warm-up has been proven to reduce ACL injuries by 50% to 70%.
- The Implementation Failure: Despite being "free" and "proven," coaches often skip it because it feels "monotonous" or takes away from "technical" ball time.
- The "Monday" Plan: The article argues that the most reliable levers are within our control:
1
2 comments
We’ve known how to stop ACL tears for 20 years, so why is the rate for girls still 8x higher than boys?
powered by
skool.com/steve-coxon-soccer-network-4997
Navigate the college soccer recruiting journey: Build a clear plan, generate coach interest in 6 months, and avoid costly mistakes.
Suggested communities
Powered by