How to Test Your Lead Magnet Ideas Before You Build Them (And Save Yourself Months of Wasted Work)

Hey everyone! 👋

Even with all the AI tools we have now to nail our avatar's psychographics, it's still really tough to know what our audience will actually want - and even tougher to predict what they'll click through to.

I've noticed this challenge coming up a lot lately. We can create detailed customer personas and think we've got it all figured out, but then we launch a lead magnet and... the response isn't quite what we hoped for.

Here's what I've learned: there's often a gap between what we think will resonate and what actually does. Even when we understand our audience deeply, the specific language, angle, or positioning that gets them to take action can be surprisingly different from what we expect.

So instead of leaving it to chance, let me share a simple testing method I use to validate lead magnet ideas before I build them.

The Click Testing Method

The concept is dead simple: create multiple versions of your lead magnet idea and see which one people actually want to click on. We're not asking them to fill out surveys or tell us what they think - we're watching what they actually DO.

Here's how it works:

Step 1: Create Your Test Variations

Take your lead magnet concept and create 9-12 different ways to position it
Focus on different pain points, different outcomes, or different angles
Keep it simple - just text on colored backgrounds (I use Canva)
Examples: "5 Email Templates That Get Responses" vs "Stop Getting Ignored: Email Scripts That Actually Work" vs "The Email Formula Top Sales Reps Use"

Step 2: Set Up Your Test

Run these as simple Facebook/Meta ads driving to a landing page
Use a $30/day budget split across all variations (you most likely won't spend anywhere near that much - I never have)
Target your ideal audience (but keep it broad enough to get data)
Let each variation get about 400 impressions

Step 3: Look for the Winners

You want a click-through rate of at least 2.5%
Cost per click should be under $0.40
The variations that hit both metrics are your winners

Step 4: Build What Actually Works

Now you know which angle resonates most
You have the exact language your audience responds to
You can build your lead magnet with confidence

Why This Actually Matters

I know this seems like extra work upfront. But here's what I've learned: spending $200-300 testing saves you from building a lead magnet that nobody wants. Plus, you end up with proven marketing copy for when you do launch.

The winners from your test become your email subject lines, your social media posts, your sales page headlines - everything. You're not just testing the lead magnet; you're testing your entire marketing message.

Quick Example from My Own Testing

I was considering a lead magnet with ChatGPT prompts for avatar research. When I tested it, here's what happened:

"ChatGPT Prompts for Better Customer Research" - 1.9% CTR, $0.38 CPC (failed)
"The Avatar Prompts That Actually Reveal What Your Customers Think" - 3.1% CTR, $0.19 CPC (winner!)
"Stop Guessing: ChatGPT Prompts for Deep Customer Insights" - 2.8% CTR, $0.23 CPC (winner!)

Guess which angles I focused on? And guess what language I used in all my marketing? Exactly.

The Bottom Line

Your audience will tell you what they want - if you know how to listen. Click testing is just a way to have that conversation at scale, with real behavior instead of opinions.

Try this with your next lead magnet idea. Test first, build second. Your download numbers (and your sanity) will thank you.

What questions do you have about this approach? Drop them below and I'll help you think through the setup! 👇

P.S. - If you want to dive deeper into this testing methodology, I've got more detailed breakdowns I can share. This is just scratching the surface of what's possible when you start validating your ideas before you build them.

0 comments

Empathic Marketing Lab

skool.com/marketing-message-mastery

From avatar to ads: full marketing training with weekly 1-on-1 private and group coaching to craft messages that resonate and campaigns that convert.

Members

Online

Admin