User
Write something
AI's Fake Wisdom & How to Notice It
I was working with ChatGPT recently on an article about the future of writing when it offered me this sentence: “The future of writing belongs not to those who surrender their judgment to AI, but to those who learn to direct it.” Sounds quite impressive, doesn’t it? There’s a pleasing symmetry, a confident rhythm, and the suggestion of a rather profound insight. But the sentence has yet to answer a critical question. Has the contrast earned its place? Surrendering judgment to AI could describe a real behavior, a genuine danger, or a feared future. If the surrounding argument has established that context, the first half carries real weight. The problem is that AI often reaches for this construction too casually. It creates an opposition before showing that the opposition matters, giving the second half of the sentence something dramatic to triumph over. Without that context, the result is rhetorical theater: the appearance of force without the intellectual work needed to justify it. Once you notice this habit, you begin seeing it everywhere. Consider another example: “Great editing isn’t about moving words around. It’s about revealing the strongest version of an idea.” Again, the construction sounds wise. Yet moving words around is one of the ways an editor reveals the strongest version of an idea. The sentence presents a method and its purpose as though they were rivals. Unless it is correcting a real misconception about editing, the contrast creates more drama than meaning. The second half then sounds revelatory because the two ideas have been made to appear more opposed than they really are. For thought leaders and communications professionals, that is a serious risk. Once readers spot the artificial opposition, the sentence can instantly weaken the authority it was meant to project. Why AI Writing Tools Do This I think there are several reasons. First, they imitate the outward appearance of persuasive writing. Contrast is a powerful rhetorical technique. Good writers use it constantly. But a meaningful contrast must reveal a difference worth noticing.
6
0
The Five Habits of Elite Editors
During my years writing and editing for The Wall Street Journal, The Economist, and Bloomberg News, I tried to understand what the best editors I worked with were doing. Five habits of mind emerged from observing them and practicing the craft myself. They underpin what I teach in A Crash Course in Writing Well. Each habit begins with an aspiration. You may hear echoes of the following five aspirations in some of your favorite essays, speeches, op-eds, and nonfiction. 1. Comprehensible They strive to make the writing easy to understand. This means removing unnecessary complexity and making sure readers can follow the reasoning without having to work too hard. Simplicity and clarity are essential here. 2. Authentic They strive to make the writing sound honest. They remove jargon, pretentious language, and artificial posturing while preserving the writer’s personality and distinctive way of expressing ideas. 3. Beautiful They strive to make the writing flow well. They smooth out the rhythm and improve structure. This is the quality I call elegance. 4. Engaging They strive to make the writing hold attention and evoke a response. They use colorful details, vivid language, and well-chosen examples to help readers feel the significance of what they are reading. This is where evocativeness matters. 5. Effective They strive to make the writing achieve the purpose for which it was written. Whether the aim is to inform, persuade, teach, or inspire, every passage should contribute. Even a beautiful sentence may need to go if it distracts from that purpose. Through practice, these five aspirations — comprehensibility, authenticity, beauty, engagement, and effectiveness — become editorial habits. They are the gold standard I absorbed from exceptional editors who were unwilling to stop at prose that was merely serviceable.
Can You Get AI to Write With Style?
For years, I’ve taught that good writing depends on four critical ingredients: Simplicity. Clarity. Elegance. Evocativeness. I presented this framework in my flagship course, Writing With Flair, long before generative AI arrived. My purpose, at the time, was to demystify writing and to show that prose that appears naturally accomplished is usually doing four quite distinct things well: - Removing what the reader does not need (simplicity). - Making its meaning unmistakable (clarity). - Arranging language with rhythm and grace (elegance). - And, when the occasion requires it, making the reader feel something (evocativeness). Lately, I’ve been applying the same framework to AI, and the results have reinforced something I increasingly believe: The better you understand writing, the better you become at prompting. The Thinking Behind the Prompt Many weak prompts lack literary or editorial direction. They say things like: “Make this better.” “Make it more professional.” “Make it engaging.” In other words, they ask AI to make decisions the writer hasn’t made. Better in what way? More professional according to whose idea of professionalism? Make it engaging through humor, tension, surprise, intimacy, or intellectual force? AI then fills that vacuum with writing that's competent on the surface, and perhaps even impressive, but which bears the airless quality of prose that hasn’t been guided by a sufficiently exacting mind. The four ingredients give us a better language for directing AI for style. Simplicity Simplicity removes needless difficulty or complication. It cuts clutter, repetition, inflated language and unnecessary detours. It respects the reader’s time without insulting their intelligence. If a report is bloated, asking AI merely to “improve” it could result in changes to the tone, a rearranged argument, and the replacement of perfectly good phrases. A more disciplined prompt would identify the actual problem: "Tighten this passage by removing repetition, inflated wording, and anything that doesn’t advance the central point. Preserve its meaning, qualifications, and professional tone."
3
0
book
i taking this book how to win friends by dale garnegie what is the conclusion of this book
1
0
Try the 'Only You' Test on Your Writing
“As soon as I realize something has been written with AI, I stop reading.” An entrepreneur friend said this to me recently. Another friend, a former Bloomberg colleague, put it more bluntly: “If they haven’t bothered to write it, why should I bother to read it?” That may be unfair to someone who has supplied the ideas and used AI only to help express them. Still, it raises a question for those of us who care about writing. How do we make sure our own thinking and personality survive the AI polish? I explore this topic in my latest article, which includes a simple “Only You” Test you can apply to your own work, with or without AI. Read more in my Intelligent Writing newsletter: https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/readers-switch-off-when-writing-sounds-like-ai-shani-raja-precc/ Warmly, Shani
3
0
1-30 of 44
Elite Writing Academy
skool.com/elitewriting
Learn To Write & Prompt Like a Pro
Leaderboard (30-day)
Powered by