May 25 • 💬 General Discussions
What Does It Actually Mean to Post a Review?
Many of you, because of what happened in the past on other platforms or previous experiences with Amazon, started believing that the main problem was:
• the content of the review
• the writing style
• or the star rating you give
But in reality, this was never the real issue.
The real problem has always been suspicious reviewer behavior and fake reviewer accounts.
We’re talking about accounts created almost exclusively to post reviews, with little or no real customer activity behind them.
And thankfully, Amazon has now become very good at identifying these patterns.
Unfortunately, this led many people to think that posting a review is somehow like taking a university exam.
But it’s not.
A review is simply a review.
You do not need to read every single page of a book to have an opinion about it.
Maybe you already know the topic well and focus only on the sections that interest you most.That is perfectly normal behavior.
And another thing that honestly surprises me is when some users believe they should intentionally post mediocre or negative ratings to “look authentic,” almost like they are judges on MasterChef.
Especially when some of the same people complain about receiving a single slightly negative review themselves.
BookVillage is built around mutual support.
If you truly dislike a book, simply avoid reviewing it or contact us privately instead of damaging the author publicly on Amazon.
If I look at my own Amazon account, my lifetime review average is around 4.6 stars and I’ve never had any issue.
Why?
Because the account is authentic and behaves like a real customer account.
On the other hand, when Amazon repeatedly removes reviews from an account, the problem is usually not the rating itself.
The problem is that Amazon detects suspicious behavior patterns, especially on accounts created mainly for reviewing ebooks and relying too on non-verified reviews.
There are no magic tricks.
Posting negative reviews instead of 5-star reviews does not “protect” your account.
And for users constantly posting mediocre ratings while expecting positive support from the community:
Trust me, these patterns become obvious very quickly. If after 10 reviews your average rating is 3.5 stars, the problem is probably not the books.
So if your dream is to become a MasterChef judge, you’ll do it outside BookVillage.
BookVillage is your ally.
11
8 comments
What Does It Actually Mean to Post a Review?
powered by
skool.com/bookvillage-amazon-reviews-1030
Learn the most effective and accessible ways to get Amazon book reviews, whether you're a beginner or an experienced KDP author.
Suggested communities
Powered by