Hi BAC Members! 🐒
I was just talking with Niel about pricing as a Line Artist, and I wanted to open up the conversation to everyone.
Terminology, in case you're unfamiliar (because I didn't know what my type of work was called until very recently): Line Work is when you have a line of people ordering balloon animals from you a la carte and paying for themselves. So, this is when you’re working in public, and you’re not paid by an organizer to provide balloons for free.
I’m sure we all know that a lot of people have the notion that $1 is an appropriate tip for a balloon. That may have been fine in the 90’s, but balloons are highly prone to inflation, so $1 doesn’t cut it anymore ;)
A single balloon typically costs $0.10, so if you get $1 for a balloon, you still have a 90% margin, which is pretty phenomenal for a business. We’re lucky that our material is generally affordable, our skill is rare, and our product is something that makes kids excited and good parents are willing to spend money to see their kids smile.
However! If you can inflate those margins (ok, I'll stop), Balloon Art can make you a TON of money. I’m not gonna say exactly how much I make, but a bad day is when I go home with less than $200, and on good days I can take home well over $1000.
Now, granted, I am living and working in the San Francisco Bay Area, a notoriously affluent part of a ludicrously wealthy nation. Plus, I’m very fast and good at making intricate balloon art, so I can charge $25-30 for a balloon animal, and many people are totally cool with it. Most other locations likely won’t accommodate prices that high, but that’s fine. These are pricing principles that should work anywhere.
It all comes down to your Menu
From what I’ve seen, every artist designs their own menu, and I love seeing other Twister’s menus, because everyone pours a lot of thought and effort into them. I constantly tweak and redesign my menu, but here is how my current menu is organized:
- I divide my designs into sections based on price, which I determine based on a) the time it takes to make that balloon, b) the amount of material it takes, and c) how much I like making that balloon (Labubus are $25 because I hate making them). I have 7 sections: $3-5, $7, $10, $15, $20, $25, & $30. 🤠Note for Americans: If you say these are “Suggested Tips” and not “Prices” then you can work in any public area in the nation. You are not selling anything 😉 You are performing and creating joy, and people are welcome to tip you for that. So, if you’re on a busy sidewalk, and the police come to tell you to stop selling things, you just say, “these are suggested tips” and you’re protected by the 1st Amendment. This also helps you get into events. I’ve walked into a lot of public events uninvited, and when the organizers come to tell me I can’t sell here, I say “No problem, I’ll leave, but I’m not selling anything. I have a menu with suggested tips, but if anyone doesn’t want to pay for a balloon, that’s fine” and they often let me stay and ask me to come back in the future. I'll keep referring to them as prices, though.
- Put the most expensive items at the TOP. This is for framing. It sets a price in the customer's mind, and then as their eye moves down the page, things get more affordable. Down at the bottom, you have your cheap, quick, 1-balloon designs. Yes, when I hand the menu to people, sometimes I hear people go “Oh my god! These are so expensive!” because they’re apparently not quite smart enough to read more than the first number, so I just gently point out the bottom section and say “The most affordable ones are at the bottom.” It's annoying, but it's a small price to pay for the amount of money I believe this strategy gets me.
- I suggest making the bottom section a range, from $5 down to whatever you’re willing to accept for a 1-balloon design. Many people are more than happy to give you $5 for a balloon sword. But, if you tell everyone it’s only $2, you will get mostly $2. If you let people decide for themselves, the people who really don’t have much money can still have access to the joy of a balloon, but the people who are willing to give you $5 will, and the average you make for a 1-balloon design will go way up. It does mean I have to explain what $3-5 means to some people, and I say “People usually pay between $3-5 for that balloon, but there’s no set price because I like to keep my balloon art accessible to everyone.” People love that, and many give the full $5 just for that line. 🤠In the USA, $3-5 is affordable for just about any family, even with multiple kids. But in other parts of the world, I’d suggest connecting it to the price of a coffee or some other common purchase the parents would make. That’s your baseline.
- Up from that, I have my 2-balloon designs, like flowers, wearable wings, etc. This is where your location will determine a good price. In SF, $7 is fine, but I recognize that that would be ridiculously high for most other places. So, you’ll have to decide what works best. Again, a range can work well, like $4-8.
- My $10 section is for quick 3-balloon animals that take about 1-2 minutes to make, and everything more complex than that are LUXURY balloons. If people just want a cheap balloon, they can get a cheap balloon. But if they want something that’s going to take 3 or more minutes of your time, skill, and effort (remember, this does take a toll on your body, so make sure you get money from it to pay for the carpal tunnel syndrome later), then they can pay more. Respect you time, effort, and skill. Anything really cool or unique that you know how to make should be a Luxury Balloon. And anything I put on display is going to be a Luxury Balloon.
- Wine Pricing: People almost never buy from the top section, so go ahead and make it expensive. It’s the same principle supermarkets use to sell premium wine. They have $50 bottles, but no one is gonna buy a $50 bottle at the supermarket. But a lot more people than you think will be willing to purchase from the next price point down. So, while I would NEVER spend $25 on a balloon animal, many people are totally cool with buying a balloon from me for $25, because at least it's not $30. The $25 section is where I have my princesses, unicorns, fairies, labubus, etc. The things that some kids REALLY want. (And any time a parent has a kid that’s being a little whiny punk about getting a unicorn, but the parent is uncomfortable with spending that much, I always offer to make a simpler, cheaper version. The kid won’t know the difference, and the parent really appreciates you being on their side)
- Make sure the information is as clear as possible. Design your menu with your customer’s eye in mind. Try to keep it uncluttered, clean, easy to read, and with the prices as clear as possible. Parents will appreciate that. They won’t be willing to wait in a line to spend an uncertain amount, but if they feel they know what’s going to happen when they get to the front of the line, they’ll be much more willing to wait.
How to discuss pricing with kids: I just avoid that if I can. Kids come up to me all the time without an adult, and I just tell them, “If you want a balloon, bring an adult over to talk to me.” Kids will say, “How much?” and you can try to explain “It depends on how complex you want the balloon to be, but they range from $3-30” and they’ll just say “Wait… how much?” So, I just tell them to rope in an adult.
When you raise your prices, it may feel bad to put something a kid wants out of reach of what their parents are willing to pay. But when you’re making more money off each balloon, you’re now free to give away free balloons to low-income families. I do it all the time. Just do it quietly, or else all the other kids will ask for a free balloon.
I would love to hear what you guys think! How does pricing work where you are? Is my experience unique, or does everyone already know all this? What barriers do you see for yourself if you try to raise your prices, and how can we brainstorm together to overcome those barriers?