Activity
Mon
Wed
Fri
Sun
Dec
Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
What is this?
Less
More
1 contribution to Fingerstyle Tab Club
🎸 Do the "Rules" of Music Really Matter?
After reading some of the comments on yesterday's post, I thought it was worth clearing something up. The guidelines I give you—and the advice you'll hear from other teachers—are there to help you, especially when you're starting out. They're a great foundation and often the easiest way to approach a piece of music. But unlike classical guitar, fingerstyle and rock guitar in general is much more flexible. Think of these "rules" as good advice rather than strict laws. If you're struggling with a passage, they're usually the best place to start, but they're not something you have to follow 100% of the time. The only thing that really matters is how it sounds. Take Jimi Hendrix. When he revolutionised lead guitar, he wasn't worrying about using the "correct" notes all the time. Or look at Merle Travis and Chet Atkins. They're both legends of fingerstyle guitar, but they didn't play in exactly the same way. And lest we forget, the drum from Def Leppard only had one arm. They all found a way that worked for them. You might have noticed that my tabs don't tell you exactly which fingers to use on your left hand. That's intentional. After more than 20 years of teaching guitar, I've seen different people play exactly the same piece in completely different ways. Different hand sizes, finger lengths, flexibility, previous injuries and experience all affect what's comfortable. There often isn't just one "correct" fingering. I've especially noticed that students who start learning later in life sometimes find the little finger harder to control because they've spent decades rarely using it independently. There's absolutely nothing wrong with adapting an arrangement to suit your own hands if it helps you play the music more comfortably. So yes, learn the rules. They're useful, and they'll make your progress much easier. But don't get hung up on them—get hung up on sounding good. However you get there. Jack 🎸
1 like • Jul 22
I’m new around here but I appreciate your comments on this. I spent a good deal of time trying and struggling to do it the “Right” way. It kept me from practicing as much as I should and led to great frustration. A while back I came to the conclusion that I will figure out which fingers go where and transitions that work best for me. I still stink but I am back to practicing more often and making some hopeful progress. On a good day it sounds like music!
1 like • Jul 22
Already working on one, thank you!
1-1 of 1
Randy Sparrow
1
3 points to level up
@randy-sparrow-6295
Retired IT guy. Continue my journey with fingerstyle.

Active 11d ago
Joined Jul 18, 2026
Sherman, Texas