Homebuyers: You’re Looking at the Wrong Metrics
Real Estate/Mortgage/Financial Stuff......(Long post, but I was inspired) Homebuyers: You’re Looking at the Wrong Metrics — and Most Mortgage Originators Aren’t Getting It Either — Because There’s More to a Good Plan Than Just Rate and Fees This is a true story about a very smart couple buying a home. They both had great jobs, strong income, and plenty of savings. On paper, they were in excellent shape. But like many buyers, they were nervous. Their rent was $2,500 a month, and their new home payment would be around $4,500 a month. That’s a big jump — especially with $3,000 a month in daycare costs. Even though their debt-to-income ratio was fine — about 29% without daycare and 40% with daycare — the higher payment made them uneasy. They started to do what many people do when they feel uncertain — they asked everyone for advice. Family, friends, coworkers — everyone had an opinion. Listening to the Wrong People At one point, they said their aunt — who actually works as a mortgage originator in another state — told them to “call Rocket Mortgage” to compare rates. Now, I respect buyers doing their due diligence to make sure they’re getting competitive pricing. That’s smart. But I couldn’t help wondering — does their aunt tell her own clients to call Rocket Mortgage to compare her rates too? Probably not. Because that’s just not how you help clients make good financial decisions. That kind of advice only creates confusion and takes the focus off what really matters. The Real Plan That Made Sense We had already built a great plan that worked. They were putting 15% down and had only $70 a month for PMI. That’s incredibly low, and it allowed them to keep over $30,000 in savings as liquidity — money that could be used for emergencies, repairs, or future opportunities. But they were focused on PMI like it was the worst thing in the world. They were ready to put that entire $30,000 into the mortgage just to remove it. That would have been a mistake. With home prices appreciating and refinance opportunities likely in the future, that PMI would disappear naturally over time. It was simply not worth losing $30,000 of liquidity to get rid of a $70 monthly charge.