Activity
Mon
Wed
Fri
Sun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
Dec
Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
What is this?
Less
More

Memberships

Rock Singing Success

263 members โ€ข Free

39 contributions to Rock Singing Success
Could We Have A Grit Technique Critique?
It seems like it's been awhile since we did one of these, where you identify various grit techniques you hear. This is Judas Priest live from 1982. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I9PjOhz3FSM At only three seconds in, Rob Halford says: "Hey Memphis"! - Is this motorboat grit? I'm not sure because I know Metallica is sort of the quintessential example of motorboat grit, but here I'm hearing the subharmonics emphasized more than I ever do in Hetfield's vocals. The only time Hetfeild came even close was maybe on ...And Justice For All and he blew put his voice. soon after. Meanwhiule, Halford is going strong at 74 years old! Clearly Halford's using a different, healthier technique than Hetfield was using on ...And Justice. Throughout the spoken intro, what is the grit technique, or grit techniques Halford is using? The spoken intro gets much grittier at 24 seconds into it when he says "The Metal Gods"! Is that Hardcore Bark? I associate Upper Grunt more like what Mick Jagger does on Start Me Up (that was a great critique/explanation you did on that)! If he isn't using Hardcore Bark when he says "The Metal Gods" and it actually is Upper Grunt, what makes Halford's Upper Grunt so much more distorted than Jagger's? MY FAVORITE QUESTION IS COMING UP - PLEASE ANSWER THE QUESTION IN THE PARAGRAPH BELOW : ) The singing starts at 47 seconds with: "We'd taken too much for granted"- Again, I can't tell if thjis is Upper Grunt of Harcore bark. Is there some sure telltale sing that it is one or the othjer, or is possible for a singer to straddle the line between Upper Grunt and Hardcore Bark? If you only answer one thing I really hope you answered what I asked in the above paragraph. At 52 seconds he sings "And all the time it had GROWN" - I put "grown" in caps because he gets a different,. more gurgly, more distorted sound on that word. How does he get that effect? It sounds so cool! Afterwards, for at least the next minute or so, it sounds like Upper Grunt - there is still nothing as gurgly sounding or as filthily distorted as on "GROWN" at 52 seconds.
0 likes โ€ข 3d
@Tamatoa Cabral Yeah, that's just my understanding of grinding based on the context in which I've seen the word used. Extreme tension or extreme compression will stress out the vocal cords anywhere - not just at a certain bridge or just with distortion. Think of all the people who have been injured singing clean vocals.
1 like โ€ข 1d
@Draven Grey That's very helpful! I only had a little idea of what grinding really is and this allowed me to understand it much better, as well as the difference between compression and constriction. I knew that twang narrows the opening, but I didn't realize it was the epiglottis that acts as the "thumb over the garden hose." Thank you!
Released an Album
I happened to release an album last week https://tothesun.bandcamp.com/album/autonomic-solipsistic First I'll say a little something about this song from it https://tothesun.bandcamp.com/track/the-shepherd-and-the-slaver It was one of the ones recorded longest ago. After it was recorded, it was brought to my attention that the way I was going about the more aggressive sort of lines in it was resulting in an epiglottal growl. When I revisited this song, I didn't really think it sounded bad and decided to keep it anyway. If I claim it as a stylistic choice, then no one has to know that I didn't have control over it. I added some overdrive to it and then added a more lifted, crisper take to the choruses to give them some variety and stand out, leaving the old line as a double. So the choruses are newer and show more of the control I've developed in avoiding that epiglottal sound. As for the other songs recorded more recently, I did consciously avoid that sound on them when singing more aggressively.
1 like โ€ข 5d
@To the Sun I can say I have never heard anything quite like this before. I'll admit to skipping ahead in places because I was looking for a melody and didn't find one but I did try. I listened to a fair amount of your song. I have read that black metal bands purposely avoid making their recordings hi-fi. They want a low-fidelity production. Was that your goal was well? If so, is it because it's part of this sub-genre, in much the same way its part of the black metal sub-genre? I can't really give a critique because I'm so unfamiliar with this style of music, but congrats on having a vision for a project and then having the perseverance to see it through to completion.
๐ŸŽง How Recording Makes You a Better Singer
Podcast Chats are where we keep the conversation going and dive deeper into the topics of our podcast episodes with you! โ–ถ๏ธ You can ๐˜„๐—ฎ๐˜๐—ฐ๐—ต this episode below or find it directly on Youtube. ๐ŸŽง You can find this episode on our website or by searching for Rock Singing Success on your favorite podcast app! โžก๏ธ ๐—ช๐—ฒ ๐˜„๐—ผ๐˜‚๐—น๐—ฑ ๐—น๐—ผ๐˜ƒ๐—ฒ ๐˜๐—ผ ๐—ธ๐—ป๐—ผ๐˜„ ๐˜†๐—ผ๐˜‚๐—ฟ ๐˜๐—ต๐—ผ๐˜‚๐—ด๐—ต๐˜๐˜€, ๐—พ๐˜‚๐—ฒ๐˜€๐˜๐—ถ๐—ผ๐—ป๐˜€ ๐—ผ๐—ฟ ๐˜๐—ฎ๐—ธ๐—ฒ๐—ฎ๐˜„๐—ฎ๐˜†๐˜€ ๐—ถ๐—ป ๐˜๐—ต๐—ฒ ๐—ฐ๐—ผ๐—บ๐—บ๐—ฒ๐—ป๐˜๐˜€! Even if you donโ€™t plan on producing your music, understanding the basics of recording and mixing is essential to becoming a better singer and musician. From finding the right microphone to improving your sound with EQ, compression, and more, join me as we explore practical production tips to elevate your vocal performance and take your recording to the next level. In this episode: - How basic production skills make you a better singer and musician - The insane value of understanding recording and mixing - How to find the RIGHT microphone for you, and why itโ€™s incredibly important - Affordable and effective soundproofing - The benefit of using reference tracks for mixing - How to use EQ and compression to enhance your vocals - Why mastering is important - Getting a full and polished sound - The importance of recording for improving your voice - You donโ€™t hear what you think you hear: why taking breaks during mixing is essential - Essential strategies to help your vocals stand out in the mix SUBSCRIBE ON YOUR FAVORITE PODCAST PLATFORM: Amazon Music/Audible Apple Deezer iHeartRadio Pandora Spotify
1 like โ€ข 5d
@Martin Sinclair Recording myself mad me realize that my grit technique used to be all wrong. I was squeezing.
Learning distortion with a "too much mass" curse
I finally understand why I've been stuck! Pushing too hard was the only repeatable way I could get distortion on notes. Fry scream has never been too hard. But real, on-demand, comfy distortion? Never. Cranking up my "gain knob" tended to just produce even cleaner, tighter tones (heavier mass) rather than the burbly grit I'm looking for. I took a break from learning distortion when I started making myself pass out in the middle of the best compressed grungy tones ~2nd passagio (G up to C#) even though my voice wasn't feeling any pain. Coming back into it in the past few months, trying to learn completely different coordination, I realize how seriously challenging it is for me to isolate adduction (heavier mass) from compression (more respiration pressure + constriction up top). This is why only "pushing" works: a huge force of wind overcoming heavy mass distorts - but too forcefully. If I could lighten up my mass while maintaining compression, then distortion would be a breeze! What's helped me learn differently this time: 1. Trying to always keep a little wind in the note - I visualize adding some of the 'h' sound (as in 'hot') to things, which took me a long time to grasp but is working out nicely. Doing it without a note sounds a bit like a constant wheeze. This seems to be part of the distortion "gain knob". 2. Using cry tilt more - Thanks to copying Draven's default singing mode, I'm currently obsessed with isolating cry exactly. Over-crying in silence with no other efforts (while doing chores, etc.) to exercise that strength and coordination, regardless of what my face decides to do. 3. More TA/CT strength-building - distorting positions are usually unstable, and more strength makes stability naturally easier. At constant pitches across my range, I do the "superhero": mmm-ee-yeh-yah-yoh-oo (my souped-up version of Maestro Kyle's "hero") with lots of quack at the y's. Doing these slowly in the tenor range feels 100% like lifting weights and *works* like gangbusters!
0 likes โ€ข 20d
When you say you can do distortion up to C#, are you talking about C#5? That's where it gets difficult for me. I can only do grit up to D#5.
Rob Halford HIts A5 OnThe First False Fold Scream Ever Recorded!
In 1976, Judas Priest recorded Sad Wings Of Destiny with Rob Halford on lead vocals and at 7:19 into the song Victim Of Changes, Halford begins what may be the first false fold scream on record. Halford absolutely does a false fold scream from about 7:19 to seven twenty two and a half seconds and you might argue that from about seven twenty two and a half seconds on, that maybe it no longer is a false fold scream and you'd be right. It's something much harder to do. At somewhere between 7:22 and 7:23, Halford's false fold scream transitions into something where the sound from the true vocal folds can be much more clearly heard despite a massive amount of distortion over his voice. Essentially from seven twenty two and a half seconds on, the false fold scream becomes a "distortion siren" that peaks at A5! It's a remarkable achievement for any vocalist, but by 1976 standards, this was the metal equivalent of what putting a man on the moon was in 1969. Here's the link https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=swiKkmcHxHY
5
0
1-10 of 39
Kenny Kendall
4
42points to level up
@kenny-kendall-9359
I love classic rock and metal. A couple years ago I started learning to play guitar, but then I decided what truly excited me was being a vocalist.

Active 7h ago
Joined Dec 25, 2025
Powered by