Worth underwriting it exactly as posted before anyone gets attached to the $2,650. 11904 Chesterfield Ave, $186,000, combined HUD rent $2,650/mo = $31,800/yr gross. The operating side, with assumptions you should replace with real bills: - Property tax: I'd budget $400-500/mo. Cuyahoga effective rates are high and the current bill may be based on an old valuation, so underwrite the post-sale reassessment number, not the seller's bill. - Insurance: $200-275/mo for a landlord policy on a 100-year-old duplex in 44108. Get a quote in hand — carriers will want the roof and panel documented. - Water/sewer/trash: $80-120/mo, and in Cleveland this usually stays with the owner. Confirm it's not on the tenant in the leases. - Management at 9% and maintenance plus capex at 14%: $238 and $371. - Vacancy 5%: $132. Section 8 turns over less, but it turns over. That's about $1,527/mo of operating cost, leaving NOI near $1,123/mo, or $13,476 a year. On $186,000 that's a 7.25% cap. Then the debt, at 25% down and 7.25%: $139,500 borrowed, P&I around $952/mo. Cash flow is roughly $170/mo, DSCR about 1.18, cash-on-cash about 4% on $51,500 in. A DSCR lender at 1.25 wants closer to $175,000 for this rent, so the asking price is about $10k rich against these assumptions. That's a negotiation, not a deal killer, but it's the number to walk in with. Change the taxes or the insurance and the whole thing moves, which is why those two get verified first. Four Section 8 specifics that matter more than the cap rate here: - A "combined HUD rent" is a seller's number. Each unit gets its own HAP contract, its own payment standard for its bedroom count and its own rent reasonableness test, so ask for the per-unit figures and check them against the current CMHA schedule yourself. The 3BR unit is where the rent usually holds and the 2BR is where it can come in under. - The existing HAP contract does not simply transfer to you. CMHA wants an ownership-change package, and rents can be reset at the next annual re-certification. So $2,650 is not locked for you — plan the deal to survive a modest downward reset, because that's the direction it usually moves.