I hear this often in the clinic, "He can do it when he wants to.” which leads families to understandably conclude: If they can do it sometimes, shouldn't they be able to do it all the time? Here's what is going on in your loved one's brain: They have reduced cognitive reserve: dementia means the brain has less capacity to compensate when tired, stressed, distracted, ill, or overwhelmed. Uneven function: different networks and abilities are affected at different rates, so performance can look surprisingly good in one setting and fall apart in another. Stress and overload matter: noise, fatigue, pain, unfamiliarity, too many steps, or emotional distress can make an ability temporarily less accessible. All of these factors can impact your loved one's performance: - fatigue - time of day - stress - illness - pain - sleep - distraction/noise - familiarity - complexity of the task - how much cueing is available - emotional state - medication effects Here's what I notice in the clinic and visiting someone's home. They may perform beautifully with therapy at 10 a.m. in a quiet environment and struggle tremendously with the “same” task at 5 p.m. after a full day. That isn’t necessarily manipulation. And it doesn't necessarily mean the earlier performance wasn't real. Being able to do something once does not mean the brain can reliably produce that performance every time. In prepping for someone to go home we look at Capacity versus reliability: the person may be able to complete the task as noted above, but not consistently, not safely. Can your loved one make a sandwich? Maybe, but can she reliably make herself something appropriate to eat every day without prompting? Can he take his medications? Maybe, but can he reliably take the correct medications, in the correct doses, at the correct time? Very different question. The skill may still exist, but the brain may not be able to reliably access it under every condition. Dementia does not always erase an ability all at once. Sometimes it makes that ability less reliable.