I like dirty water when it’s warm. I like to have 1-2ft of visibility. If the water is below 50 degrees I like to downsize my lures, so I prefer cleaner water. All of that can change depending on the lake too. If the lake is typically really clear, I don’t seem to do as well when it gets dirty. Wilson lake was a prime example this year, it’s typically clear and I typically catch a lot of good fish, but it was low and dirty this summer and I didn’t catch any.