Here is the rest of the outline, as I conceive of it now. Although I wrote down the theme, I'm not quite convinced that that is what it is. I have a feeling that I need to work on the story more to figure it out.
Chapter 4 — Learning Lydia
Chapter Summary: As the narrator spends time with Lydia in Boulder, she learns how Lydia navigates the world without sight and how living with her requires patience, attention, and adaptation. Through shared routines, the narrator begins to change her pace and way of seeing.
Lesson Learned: Love is learned through attention and adjustment, not control.
Chapter 5 — Letting Go (Without Letting Go)
Chapter Summary: Circumstances shift, and Lydia is no longer fully in the narrator’s care. The narrator continues visiting Lydia through multiple moves, aware that their bond exists without ownership or security. Before leaving Boulder, she says a final goodbye and speaks a private prayer.
Lesson Learned: Some bonds matter deeply even when we cannot keep or protect them.
Chapter 6 — The Miracle I Didn’t Name
Chapter Summary: Years later, the narrator receives an unexpected message offering her the chance to adopt Lydia. After logistical complications and a tense journey, Lydia arrives in California and immediately recognizes the narrator, as if no time has passed.
Lesson Learned: What returns to us does not come back as a gift alone—it comes with responsibility.
Chapter 7 — The Goodbye I Couldn’t Stop
Chapter Summary: Lydia’s health begins to fail, and love shifts into vigilant caretaking. The narrator confronts the limits of effort, hope, and intervention as Lydia’s body declines despite devotion and care.
Lesson Learned: Love cannot prevent loss; it can only accompany it.
Chapter 8 — Once, and Only Once
Chapter Summary: After Lydia’s death, the narrator reckons with grief and absence. In an attempt to recreate what was lost, she adopts another cat, Nebula, only to realize that love cannot be duplicated. Over time, she learns to love again in a different way, without erasing what came before.
Lesson Learned: Each relationship is singular; love cannot be replaced, only re-entered differently.
Theme
Overall Lesson: An answered wish does not undo loss—it teaches us what it truly means to love, to grieve, and to accept impermanence.