Thought For The Day
The Cursed Bag of Holding
In Dungeons & Dragons, there is a magical object called a Bag of Holding.
Basic rules:
- The bag is much larger on the inside than on the outside. Its interior is an extradimensional space.
- It can hold up to 500 pounds of material, with a maximum volume of 64 cubic feet.
- Objects placed inside can normally be retrieved.
- If the bag is turned inside out, everything stored inside spills out unharmed.
- If the bag is punctured, torn, or overloaded, it is destroyed, and its contents are scattered into the Astral Plane.
The Bag of Holding has been cursed so that anything placed inside it can never be brought out again.
The bag otherwise functions normally. Objects can still be placed inside, and its extradimensional space continues to exist. However, once something enters, it cannot be retrieved.
Imagine placing a simple stone inside. You reach in to retrieve it, but the curse prevents its removal.
Now comes the thought experiment:
What happens if you turn the bag inside out?
Under the original rules, turning the bag inside out forces its contents to spill into the outside world. But the curse explicitly prevents anything inside from being brought out.
So what happens when two magical principles contradict one another?
Does turning the bag inside out circumvent the curse? Does the curse prevent the inversion? Or does something entirely different happen to the extradimensional space?
If the inside becomes the outside, has anything actually crossed the boundary?
Think about this in terms of dimensional space, magical laws, intention, and the relationship between containment and reality.
What do you believe would happen, and why?
2
1 comment
Thought For The Day
powered by
skool.com/the-foundation-outer-circle-5292
Look beneath the noise. Clear the friction, balance the internal force and form, and stand uncompromised in the quietude of the True I. Enter.
Suggested communities
Powered by