I see this all the time when I audit communities.
The thinking is:
“If I make Free amazing, I’ll get lots of members and eventually convert all of them.”
But you don’t need to convert everyone.
If you have 500 members and 20% upgrade at $49/month, that’s 100 Premium members and $4,900 MRR.
At $99/month?
That same 100 members is $9,900 MRR.
Free doesn’t need to contain everything you know.
Free helps them get started.
Premium helps them get the transformation.
That distinction matters.