Thanks to the advice I have received here i finally did it!
I now have free, basic and VIP tiers.
Given I'm in the Aussie Homesteading niche I have called them Front Paddock, Top Paddock and Home Paddock. They are free, $19 month ($190 annual) and $99 month ($950 annual).
I only have 50 members but given all the advice here I wanted to make it clear to my members that it was always going to have a paid element to the community. I have no problem asking for money for my expertise, I know I am good at what I do and have experience that others don't have.
I'm still nervous as hell putting it out there. Wish me luck everyone.
Thank you for all the free stuff, I can't wait to see what you have in VIP