My Thoughts on the Manosphere documentary
Hey brother, I watched the Louis Theroux Manosphere documentary three times last week. Not because I enjoyed it. But because something kept nagging at me that I couldn't quite put into words. Everyone is talking about it. The hypocrisy, the hostility toward women, the performative confidence. And they're not wrong. But to me, all of that is surface level. What bothers me most is what's underneath it. These men are exploiting the genuine pain of young men who never got what they needed. And are calling it guidance. Here's the thing though. None of us got properly educated about what being a man means. Not really. No one sat us down and said: this is who you are now, this is how you do it, we've got you. We all just figured it out as we went. And we all, in our own ways, paid the price for that. That absence is ancient. It goes back further than feminism, further than social media, further than anything we can easily blame. Somewhere along the way, the rituals that turned boys into men just quietly disappeared. And nobody noticed until the consequences started showing up everywhere. The manosphere showed up into that vacuum. And for all their many flaws, at least they're offering something. A sense of direction. A feeling of brotherhood. An answer to the question every uninitiated boy is quietly asking: am I enough, and do I belong? The tragedy is that their answer to that question is so deeply immature. Because that's what this actually is. Not toxic masculinity. Immature masculinity. The fantasy of what a teenage boy thinks being a man looks like. Rebellious, edgy, status-obsessed, hostile, performative. It's not masculinity that went wrong. It's masculinity that never got the chance to grow up. And when you see it that way, the anger fades a little. What you're left with is something closer to sadness. These are uninitiated men, inspiring uninitiated boys, in an endless loop. The ones drawn to this content aren't bad people. They're hungry people. Hungry for exactly what you and I are still working toward ourselves: