PTN INSIDER REPORT 009 / Artists Wrestle With Ethics in Streaming / September 19, 2025

📍 1. CONTEXT / INDUSTRY SHIFTMassive Attack has formally requested that their full catalogue be removed from Spotify (globally) in protest of Spotify CEO Daniel Ek’s investment via his VC firm in Helsing, a defense tech company developing AI-powered systems (including drones) and weapons systems.

At the same time, Massive Attack joined the “No Music for Genocide” campaign, under which more than 400 artists and labels are asking that their music be geo-restricted in Israel as a protest against military action in Gaza and ongoing human rights concerns.

This move escalates a growing trend: artists pushing not just for better royalties or exposure, but for ethical alignment with their platforms. It forces questions about the moral responsibility of streaming services, the separation (or lack thereof) between personal investments by execs and the platforms themselves, and how culture intersects with politics & human rights.

📂 2. CASE FOCUS / BREAKDOWN

• Massive Attack’s action — Formal request to their label (Universal Music Group) to remove music from Spotify globally, and geo-blocking in Israel for all streaming platforms.

• No Music for Genocide campaign — Coalition of 400+ artists and labels, raising awareness and taking collective action via streaming restrictions, to protest alleged genocide & human rights violations.

• Spotify / Helsing connection — Daniel Ek’s VC investment in Helsing, a defense-AI company. Spotify maintains the two businesses are separate, but artist backlash shows audiences see overlap.

📈 3. STRATEGY OR BUSINESS PRINCIPLE

Ethical alignment is becoming a core litmus test for both artists and consumers.

-Platform leaders’ outside investments are under scrutiny, not just platform policies.

-Collective action by artists amplifies impact, forcing labels and DSPs to address values, not just royalties.

-Geo-blocking is emerging as a new form of protest, expanding how artists weaponize distribution rights.

✅ 4. TAKEAWAYS / ACTION STEPS

REVIEW PLATFORM LEADERSHIP SCRUTINYKnow where your platform’s money flows. Expect rising artist/consumer demand for transparency.

2. STRENGTHEN ETHICAL TRANSPARENCY - Artists, ask early about exec affiliations before tying your catalog to a service.

3. PREPARE FOR VALUES-BASED PRESSURE - Supervisors, brands, and studios must factor ethical optics into music decisions, not just cost.

4. EXPLORE DISTRIBUTION FLEXIBILITY - Artists should diversify: Bandcamp, direct-to-fan, selective partnerships offer levers of control.

🔬 PTN LENS – Visual or Language Framing

Frame this moment like a moral amplifier: streaming used to amplify only revenue. Now it amplifies values, too.

🔍 5. FINAL REFLECTION / CREATOR LENS

Creators and rights-holders are increasingly being asked: “What do you stand for?” Not just, “What do you release?” This shift means neutrality is no longer neutral. For artists, the choice of where your work lives is also the choice of what your work represents.

📚 And that’s the PTN difference.

We don’t just analyze the system - we operate inside it, with our eyes wide open.

Right now, we play by the rules we’ve been given - the briefs, the splits, the backend grind. But everything we build - the workflows, the trust, the visibility - is designed to give us the position to change those rules.

We’re not just getting through the gates. We’re training creators to build their own floor once they’re in — and eventually, to redesign the whole building.

------------

🔗 SOURCE SIGNALS – Full Links

The Guardian – Massive Attack remove music from Spotify to protest CEO Daniel Ek’s investment in AI military

https://www.theguardian.com/music/2025/sep/18/massive-attack-remove-music-from-spotify-to-protest-ceo-daniel-eks-investment-in-ai-military

Pitchfork – Massive Attack Say They’ll Remove Music From Spotify

https://pitchfork.com/news/massive-attack-say-theyll-remove-music-from-spotify/

CMU – Massive Attack pull music off Spotify over Ek’s weapons investments and join No Music For Genocide campaign

https://completemusicupdate.com/massive-attack-pull-music-off-spotify-over-eks-weapons-investments-and-join-no-music-for-genocide-campaign/

Euronews – Massive Attack pull their music from Spotify and platforms in Israel

https://www.euronews.com/culture/2025/09/19/massive-attack-pull-their-music-from-spotify-and-platforms-in-israel

6 comments