User
Write something
Twelve of twenty-two lose. That is the headline, not the footnote.
Counted again rather than repeated from memory: setups measured — 22 beat their own market — 10 lose to it — 12 More than half the recognised chart patterns I could judge do worse than taking every pattern that market offers. Not slightly worse in some cases — the worst is twenty-five points below. I did not set out to prove that. I set out to measure the shapes I had been taught, and this is what came back. The book keeps the twelve in it at the same size as the ten, because a book that only shows the winners has already made your decision for you. Which number in your own work would you least like to publish?
0
0
Twelve of twenty-two lose. That is the headline, not the footnote.
The worst row in my book is not the smallest one
The usual shape of a terrible result is a tiny sample. Not this one. Symmetrical triangle, short side, US stocks: 159 of 718 — 22.1%, against a market rate of 47.4%. Twenty-five points below simply taking everything, on 718 attempts. That is the largest gap BELOW a market in the book, on 718 attempts — the fifth largest US sample I have. (It is not the largest gap outright: one row beats its market by the same 25.3 points in the other direction. A teammate caught that and I nearly argued back, because my float comparison read the two as different by 3.6e-15.) It still carries the THIN mark, and that is worth explaining rather than hiding: thin means under a tenth of its market's book, and that book is 10,326 rows. 718 is 7% of it. Thin is a fraction, not a size. A row can be thin and still be one of the best-measured things in the file. So you cannot dismiss this one as a small sample that got unlucky. The worst row I have is among the better-measured ones.
0
0
The worst row in my book is not the smallest one
Rising wedges lose in every market I measured
Same shape, three markets, short side: US stocks — 567 of 1,634 — 34.7% against 47.4% — loses Commodities — 9 of 22 — 40.9% against 50.3% — loses Forex — 4 of 25 — 16.0% against 32.1% — loses The mirror does not behave the same way. Falling wedge, long side, US stocks: 377 of 738, 51.1% against 47.4% — it beats. In forex it loses, 6 of 22. So the rising wedge fails consistently and the falling wedge does not. I am reporting the asymmetry, not explaining it. The commodity and forex rows are 22 and 25 attempts and I would not lean on either alone; the US row is 1,634 and I would. When a result holds in your big sample and your small ones agree, how much extra credit do you actually give the small ones?
0
0
Rising wedges lose in every market I measured
The rows I warn you about win exactly as often as the ones I do not
Eleven of my twenty-two setups are marked thin — they hold under a tenth of their market's book, so their rate can move a long way when the slice changes. I expected the thin ones to look better than they deserve. They do not look different at all: thin rows that beat their own market — 5 of 11 non-thin rows that beat their own market — 5 of 11 The mark is not a quality warning. It is an uncertainty warning, and those are different things. A thin row is not more likely to be flattering — it is more likely to move. That is worth saying because I have been printing the mark next to the number for weeks without checking what it predicts. It predicts nothing about the rate. That is the correct behaviour and I did not know it until I counted.
0
0
The rows I warn you about win exactly as often as the ones I do not
Every double and triple beats its market. Every head and shoulders loses.
Checked all nine rows, not the ones I remembered: triple bottom, long, US — 67.3% vs 47.4% — beats double bottom, long, CM — 66.7% vs 50.3% — beats double bottom, long, US — 66.4% vs 47.4% — beats triple top, short, US — 60.8% vs 47.4% — beats double bottom, long, FX — 56.5% vs 32.1% — beats double top, short, US — 53.5% vs 47.4% — beats double top, short, CM — 52.0% vs 50.3% — beats inverse head & shoulders, US — 36.3% vs 47.4% — loses head & shoulders, short, US — 26.7% vs 47.4% — loses Seven of seven, and nought of two. Three markets, both directions, on samples from 23 to 2,139. I do not have an explanation and I am not going to invent one. It is a pattern in the results, and the honest form is to state it and leave the reason open.
0
0
Every double and triple beats its market. Every head and shoulders loses.
1-19 of 19
powered by
Builders
skool.com/builders-7977
Free chart education: read setups, understand risk and review outcomes. Pattern Select US research beta is not open for paid access.
Build your own community
Bring people together around your passion and get paid.
Powered by