💎 Offer Hypothesis - Tia / Verify with AI
Before we jump in… HUGE congratulations to ! 🥳
Tia finished #1 on last week’s leaderboard with 59 points and chose a One-Time Premium Review Pass as her reward: a personalized Offer Hypothesis for Verify with AI.
She showed up, contributed, and earned it—and now the rest of us get to learn from what may be hiding inside her offer too. 👀
And if you’ve been curious about Premium, this is a little peek at the kind of personalized diagnostic feedback available there. Tia just earned her pass by taking the top spot.
Alright, Tia… let’s get into it. 👇
—————-
THE MACHINE ISN’T THE OFFER
— I went into this expecting your biggest issue to be pricing.
You already suspect the $19 Premium tier may need to change, and with Free, Premium, and VIP all live before the first sale, that seemed like the obvious place to look.
But the more I looked…
The less I think price is the first problem.
I think you may have three different businesses sitting inside one community—and the most buyable one isn’t the one you’re leading with. 👀
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
WHAT’S ALREADY WORKING
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
“Stop building blind.”
That’s strong.
Almost every creator has spent hours making a post, offer, or product only to discover nobody wanted it.
And this is memorable:
“Run it past 10,000 synthetic customers and get a verdict in minutes.”
But the strongest thing on your page may be the part where your own simulation returned:
NOT YET.
You didn’t hide the result. You published it and shared the recommendation:
“Prove it on one real idea before asking me to commit.”
That creates trust—and it reveals exactly what the offer needs next.
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
WHAT I THINK IS HAPPENING 👀
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
Your visitor arrives wanting help with one decision:
“Should I post this?”
“Is this offer worth building?”
“What am I missing before I launch?”
But the paid offer quickly asks them to:
• build a local simulation machine
• create synthetic people
• turn information into datasets
• learn how to run the system themselves
That’s interesting technology.
But it’s not necessarily what they came for.
The buyer doesn’t wake up wanting a simulation machine.
They wake up wanting to avoid wasting three weeks building the wrong thing.
The machine is the mechanism.
The safer decision is the product.
Right now, you’re asking people to buy the laboratory before they’ve experienced the value of one test.
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
THE REAL OFFER
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
I don’t think your strongest promise is:
“Build your own simulation machine.”
It may be:
“Catch the objection before your real audience does.”
Or:
“Stress-test your next post, price, or launch before spending real time and money on it.”
That gives people a result they can experience before deciding whether they want your complete system.
And I think there are three offers hiding inside this idea.
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
OPTION 1 — THE BEFORE-YOU-BUILD TEST ⭐
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
Price idea:
$19–$39 one-time
Promise:
“Before you build or publish it, find the biggest reason your audience may hesitate—and what to change first.”
The buyer submits one post, advertisement, price, offer, or launch idea.
You return:
• a GO / REVISE / RETHINK result
• the strongest reactions
• the biggest objections
• the part most likely to lose people
• the one change you recommend testing first
This is the option I would test first.
It creates the shortest path to:
• your first sale
• a real customer conversation
• a before-and-after example
• proof that the simulation produces useful insight
They don’t need to install anything or commit monthly.
They only need one real decision they’re afraid of getting wrong.
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
OPTION 2 — THE VERIFY WITH AI LAB
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
Price idea:
$19–$29/month
This would be for creators who regularly produce content, advertisements, offers, and launches.
The promise becomes:
“Never launch an important idea without testing it first.”
It could include weekly test threads, live breakdowns, audience-building templates, and a limited number of personal tests.
That creates a recurring reason to stay.
Building the machine is usually a one-time project.
Making new decisions is recurring.
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
OPTION 3 — CUSTOM AUDIENCE MACHINE
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
Founding price idea:
$149–$299 one-time, depending on the work involved
You build someone’s custom synthetic audience, simulation setup, buyer profiles, datasets, and testing prompts—then help them run their first test.
This could become the premium service for creators or businesses producing enough material to need their own system.
But it requires the most trust.
Let people buy the result before asking them to buy the infrastructure.
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
WHAT I’D TEST NEXT 🚀
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
I wouldn’t change the $19 membership price yet.
The price hasn’t received a fair test because the transformation still isn’t clear enough.
Instead, find 10 people who already have something they plan to publish, price, or launch within the next seven days.
Offer three founding Before-You-Build Tests at $29.
Something like:
“I saw you’re getting ready to launch this. I’m opening three founding spots for a new test where I run one real offer, post, price, or launch through a synthetic version of the intended audience. You’ll receive the biggest objections, what appears strongest, and the one change I’d make before going live. Want me to run yours?”
Then follow what happens after they use the recommendation.
The most valuable proof won’t be:
“We ran 10,000 simulations.”
It will be:
“The simulation caught this. We changed it. Here’s what happened when the real audience saw it.”
If people want you to continue running the tests, the service may be the real offer.
If they start asking how to run unlimited tests themselves, that’s evidence for the membership.
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
A FEW QUICK WINS ⚡
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
• Consider saying “synthetic audience” instead of “synthetic customers.” It feels more accurate and creates less trust friction.
• Explain exactly what someone receives with a “verdict.”
• Keep Jaralock and the technical setup behind the result. The tools strengthen the mechanism, but they shouldn’t have to sell the offer.
• Remove “other free AI resources” from VIP. The most expensive option should feel more focused—not more miscellaneous.
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
MY OVERALL HYPOTHESIS
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
The idea itself has real potential.
The problem isn’t that $19 is obviously too high or too low.
People are being asked to understand and trust the complete system before experiencing its simplest useful result.
I’m confident the offer sequence should change.
I’m much less confident about the final pricing because nobody has directly tested a specific paid result yet.
So I wouldn’t build more tiers or make more ads right now.
I’d use the machine to help one person make one better decision—and charge for that result.
You don’t need to prove that a synthetic audience can predict everything.
You need to prove that Tia’s process can catch something useful before the real audience sees it.
The machine may be impressive.
The clearer decision is what people will buy.
Who already has something going live this week that could become your first real before-and-after test?
5
14 comments
Joshua Guerrero
8
💎 Offer Hypothesis - Tia / Verify with AI
powered by
Earn Your First $1 on Skool
skool.com/anchor-week-1181
New to Skool or stuck building your community? Use Builder OS to find what’s holding you back and test one move toward your first sale.
Build your own community
Bring people together around your passion and get paid.
Powered by