@Randy George This review by Sensei Williams contains in a few pages more truth about violence, preparation, honor and valour than anything I have ever read. It also clarifies something that I was recently discussing as “finding my tribe”. I’ve spend most of my life working in health care where even the willingness to use force is condemned and to prepare for real danger is entirely absent. As I pursued firearms training and then began reloading and shooting more frequently, there were many who seemed to be living out a kind of fantasy that begins in America (I include Canada in this) with TV and film depicting the Wild West (I had fake perl handled pistols by age 4) and then carried over into a deluge of action/adventure or revenge movies where the people using violence rarely carried the weight of what it means to take life.. I met very few people outside of the military who seemed to understand that dimension and who did not engage in fantasy of being invincible with god-like power (by wielding a gun). When I worked with soldiers, the most common source of operational stress “injury” involved seeing death up close and delivering it to others.. I only saw those who struggled with how to think about taking life whereas I assumed that most had some way to metabolize this so they could still function at home without being crushed by their experiences. What I did see was evidence of a male bonding that was at an entirely different level than I had seen in health care or even working with other psychologists in prison (with one exception). Many times I heard of men who served on the same FOB (forward operating base) where they took fire, killed and were killed on patrol, talk about taking care of one another… not male bonding around athletics but real bonding that could be mistaken for “love” but the word does not capture what I saw- true and near absolute “commitment” comes closer, a “deep care and concern”… repeatedly I heard of guys who would drop in on others they thought were struggling and really go the extra mile to try to help in all sorts of ways including dragging them off to see me.. I came to envy that type of relationship and realized that there was something in me, I don’t know why, that had always been there to offer to others but with whom there was nothing remotely like it reciprocated.. I suspect that one part of the answer is that for generations now (since WWII) we have lived in peace and let others fight for us in remote places… I believe that had North American come under attack and armies mobilized across the civilian population that commitment to others would change fairly quickly… It is an extremely “wrong” (in many circles) thing to say but peace has made men soft and rather hollow- they seek something but rarely find it and when they do, it is a pale and thin replica of the real thing (as in sports or even great friends from High School etc…). I never had a son but suspect that bond when healthy contains the unspoken feeling that “I would die to protect you” - buried deep in many cases, a pity… Defense of family comes a bit closer but tends in America to be tied to what might be called weapons fetishes… this or that weapon has the mightiest power to ward off threats (which for most people are very remote) but of course depends on your neighborhood… mine neighborhood was Leave it to Beaver middle class but we did get into scraps when we hung out where my best friend lived… a rougher working class hood with rudimentary gangs… I do wonder about gangs and the power they have in luring men to them and getting them to transgress their own moral values in pursuit of belonging… Most or perhaps all of these male gatherings still fall short in many ways of a values, and honor centered band of brothers at arms.. As one inmate that I met when I ran a “rehabilitation” unit in the provincial jail said, “I’ve never found what I was looking for and I think we would all have been better off if there had been a Big War”… Interesting…