ā How to Give Feedback in This Community
A gentle guide for reflection, not critique. In Community Share, we treat feedback as a mirrorānot a red pen. This community is built on care, curiosity, and creative courage, so hereās how we hold each otherās work with intention. --- š Before Anything Else: Consent Matters Not everyone wants feedback every time they share. When you post your writing, please use one of these tags: ⢠[Reflection Only] ā no feedback, just space to be witnessed ⢠[Gentle Feedback Welcome] ā light reflections only ⢠[Open to Feedback] ā questions + deeper reflections allowed And when responding to someone else? Always check their tag first. Never assume. --- ⨠Our Community Feedback Principles 1. Celebrate the Spark Start by naming what moved you. What line echoed? What image stayed with you? Example: āThis line felt like stepping into a stormāsoft but electric.ā 2. Ask, Donāt Assume We use questions instead of directives. Example: āIām wondering what would happen if you let this image stand alone?ā 3. Speak to Emotion, Not Technique Your job isnāt to āfixā a poem. Itās to reflect what it made you feel. 4. No Editing Someoneās Voice Weāre not rewriting peopleās work here. Weāre witnessing it. 5. Response Over Revision Tell them what resonated, what you pictured, what stayed with you. --- š How I Give Feedback (as your facilitator) If you request feedback directly, Iāll offer: ⢠reflections on metaphor usage ⢠emotional resonance ⢠your strongest images ⢠gentle questions to deepen the work No grammar critiques. No rewriting your poem. Just clarity, compassion, and craft awareness. You may also submit work privately for light feedback or for consideration in our Featured Poem of the Week. --- šæ This Community Is Built on Care You never need to share. You never need to edit. Being witnessed is enough. Your voice is welcome hereāraw, tender, unpolished, powerful. If we treat each otherās writing with the same tenderness we wish for our own, this space will thrive.