The Value of Targeting, Part 3: Why More Traffic Isn’t the Answer
A common reaction to low conversions is simple: get more traffic. At first glance, this seems logical. If 1 out of 100 visitors converts, then surely 10,000 visitors will solve the problem. But that assumes all visitors are equal—which they aren’t. Going back to our fishing analogy: if you’re fishing with bait that attracts every fish, adding more ponds doesn’t fix the problem. You’re still pulling up the same ratio of target fish to non-target fish—just faster and at higher cost. In fact, scaling untargeted traffic often makes losses grow faster than profits. This is why some marketers say, “Ads don’t work,” when what they really mean is, “Untargeted ads don’t work.” Targeting isn’t about volume. It’s about selectivity. Tomorrow, we’ll explore how targeting at different stages of the funnel changes everything.