Activity
Mon
Wed
Fri
Sun
Dec
Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
What is this?
Less
More
1 contribution to A System For Living Tough
How bad is hypocrisy? What is it, even?
We've all been trained to think that hypocrisy is a bad thing. I'm not here to challenge that per se, but rather to challenge the scale on which we're discussing human behaviors. The point is that it is a spectrum, the spectrum rather than a binary. And there are worse things than hypocrisy. For instance, hypocrisy... could actually be described as just giving good advice, making solid recommendations that you yourself can't follow. But is that better or worse than giving bad advice? If I advise you to shower, but I didn't shower myself. Does it make the advice invalid? Not at all. In fact, the only thing it does is to give the person receiving the good advice, an excuse not to take it. So, hypocrisy is actually not... very bad at all. Because it's functionally always good advice. That's just a little challenging. to act on. Which then... gives the person who's being challenged and excused to not act on it. But not on the basis of the advice being invalid, rather just on the... questioning of the authority of the person, giving the advice.
2 likes • Oct 3
This reframe is genuinely interesting Kaveh 😊 The distinction between the validity of advice and the authority of the advisor is where it gets really sharp. Most people conflate the two you don't do it yourself so why should I listen?" But that's actually a logical fallacy dressed up as a moral objection. If anything, a hypocrite giving good advice might understand the value of that advice more deeply precisely because they struggle to follow it themselves. The smoker who tells you not to smoke isn't wrong. What I'd push back on slightly isn't there a threshold where the gap between what someone preaches and what they practice becomes so wide that it genuinely undermines trust, even if the advice itself remains technically valid?
1-1 of 1
Joy Smith
1
4 points to level up
@joy-smith-3730
enthusiast

Active 22h ago
Joined Oct 3, 2026