Activity
Mon
Wed
Fri
Sun
Dec
Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
What is this?
Less
More

Owned by Josh

A free community for PMs, engineers and founders building product sense in the AI era.

69 contributions to Product Management Circle
Define AI Product Manager
I my current role now is A product manager or product manager, agentic. When I look at the role that I have and the work that I do versus what the market says is an AI product manager they differ. I’m not making decisions about what models to use or doing any research that would be considered “agentic”. The product I work on is a genetic, but only one portion of it is. However, one of the best parts of this role is actually given access to ADO and I get access to the code repository. This is a blessing because it allows me to interact with a code before developing a feature. It has also allowed me to find ways to resolve problems that customers have presented to the team. I learned our product in two days from a single prompt when I did not understand it entirely from all the conversations that I’ve had because it isn’t well documented and I was able to create product documentation from the code base. That’s pretty exciting. I just wanted to share that here. Perhaps it helps somebody else.
0 likes • 8d
Scharlette, love this. Reading the codebase to learn the product in two days is a real edge, and turning it into docs the team didn’t have is the kind of thing I’d put on a resume. On the title question, I think “AI PM” covers two different jobs that people mash together: 1. PMs who build AI products. They own model behavior, evals, failure modes, cost and latency tradeoffs, and how users come to trust the output. 2. PMs who use AI to do the PM job. That’s what you just described, and it’s quickly becoming table stakes for every PM. Most job posts and interview loops that say “AI PM” mean #1. So here’s where I would push. You said only one part of your product is agentic. That part is your way in. You don’t need to pick models to own it. Start asking: - How do we know the agent did the right thing? What’s our eval? - What happens when it’s wrong, and who notices? - What does each run cost, and is it worth it? - Where does the user need to stay in the loop? Own those answers for even one feature and you’ll have a real AI PM story to tell, not just the title. One caution on the code-generated docs: code tells you what the product does, not why. Run them past an engineer before they become the source of truth. Otherwise you’ll end up writing down accidents as if they were decisions.
[Start Here] Welcome to Product Management Circle
Welcome. Three things to do first: 1. Add a photo and a one-line headline to your profile. 2. Introduce yourself in the comments below. Tell us your role, what you're building, and one decision you're working through right now. 3. Take a course in the Classroom. Jobs To Be Done Basics is the best place to start. Ground rules: this is a peer learning space. No pitching, booking links or "DM me" in the main feed. Service promos go in the Promos category. Specific stories and lessons are always welcome. About me: I'm Josh. I've spent nearly 20 years in product at Meta, Google, PayPal, Walmart and Nest, and I was the first PM hire at Vivid Labs. Now I coach PMs through interviews and promotions and work with founders as a fractional product lead.
1 like • Aug 26
@Ashokraj Vinayagam Indeed a completely different mindset than software only consumer PMs. There are parallels to what you are experiencing in industries like banking, finance, healthcare and insurance. The trade off and prioritization skills you are learning in the railroad industry are of great value. Have you thought about sharing that (or another) work story on Skool or other platforms? We could all benefit from diverse perspectives on what it means to be a PM.
0 likes • 12d
@Ashokraj Vinayagam There is no lack of books, podcasts and YouTube videos about how to PM. The path that works for many is to have a coach challenge and mentor them to grow and learn. I offer a group coaching product to do just that.
It's Thursday, so here's my favorite product sense question.
What does your user's Thursday look like? I ask it of every founder I work with. Most struggle with it the first time. They start describing the product. Or the onboarding flow. Or the team that would build it. So I ask again. Where are they at 8am? What are they trying to get done? What gets in the way? The day gives you the segments. A parent packing lunches at 7am with one free hand is a different user from the same parent at a desk at 2pm. Same age, same income, different problem. And the problem worth solving usually shows up somewhere in that day, before anyone opens an app. Try it on the product you own. Write two sentences about your user's Tuesday without naming your product. If that's hard, you just learned something. I built a free quiz that shows where your product sense is strongest and weakest. Link in the first comment.
0 likes • 16d
Here's the link: https://joshatlas.co/product-sense-score
Score your product sense on your own initiative
I've been building something for the last couple of weeks and I'd like you to try it before I share it more widely. It's a product sense quiz, but it runs on your own initiative rather than a made-up prompt. You tell it what you're working on, answer eight questions about how you've handled it, and write two sentences. Claude reads the two sentences against the rubric I use with clients and explains the score. Takes about ten minutes. At the end you get a score out of 30 and the ORBIT dimension where you're weakest. joshatlas.co/product-sense-score If you take it, tell me in the comments which dimension came up weakest and whether that matched your own read. I'm still calibrating the written-answer scoring, so if the score feels wrong I want to hear that most of all. A couple of people have already pointed out questions that were off and I rewrote them. 😃
0
0
Your company gave you AI training. Your Tuesday didn't change.
If you're a PM juggling multiple products, the painful part isn't learning another AI tool. It's the PRD you have to draft again, the status update you have to pull together every week, or the feedback you still haven't had time to sort through. You might already be comfortable with Claude. Your company might even offer AI training. But knowing what the tool can do isn't the same as having a workflow that saves you time on your actual work. I coach product managers, and I use Claude Skills I built to handle the busy work in my own coaching practice. I'm testing a four-week pilot where we pick one recurring task in your week, build a reusable AI workflow around it within your company's rules, and keep your judgment in the loop. The goal is a real deliverable and hours back each week, not another course you finish and forget. Comment "pilot" and I'll send you the outline.
0 likes • Oct 1
@Ebere Egbe Thank you for the reply! https://docs.google.com/document/d/1J-aXwtdYGFlJNK4IEZXBx0kDtUnf5XpqlrjS-9cM4ns/edit?usp=drivesdk
0 likes • Oct 2
Would love your thoughts on the outline.
1-10 of 69
Josh Atlas
4
70 points to level up
@josh-atlas-6079
Founder of the Product Management Circle Helping PMs future proof their careers

Active 11h ago
Joined Oct 16, 2025
ENTJ